A new microspore embryogenesis system under low temperature which mimics zygotic embryogenesis initials, expresses auxin and efficiently regenerates doubled-haploid plants in Brassica napus
BMC Plant Biology volume 12, Article number: 127 (2012)
Microspore embryogenesis represents a unique system of single cell reprogramming in plants wherein a highly specialized cell, the microspore, by specific stress treatment, switches its fate towards an embryogenesis pathway. In Brassica napus, a model species for this phenomenon, incubation of isolated microspores at 32°C is considered to be a pre-requisite for embryogenesis induction.
We have developed a new in vitro system at lower temperature (18°C) to efficiently induce microspore embryogenesis throughout two different developmental pathways: one involving the formation of suspensor-like structures (52.4%) and another producing multicellular embryos without suspensor (13.1%); additionally, a small proportion of non-responsive microspores followed a gametophytic-like development (34.4%) leading to mature pollen. The suspensor-like pathway followed at 18°C involved the establishment of asymmetric identities from the first microspore division and an early polarity leading to different cell fates, suspensor and embryo development, which were formed by cells with different organizations and endogenous auxin distribution, similar to zygotic embryogenesis. In addition, a new strategy for germination of microspore derived embryos was developed for achieving more than 90% conversion of embryos to plantlets, with a predominance of spontaneous doubled haploids plants.
The present work reveals a novel mechanism for efficient microspore embryogenesis induction in B. napus using continuous low temperature treatment. Results indicated that low temperature applied for longer periods favours an embryogenesis pathway whose first division originates asymmetric cell identities, early polarity establishment and the formation of suspensor-like structures, mimicking zygotic embryogenesis. This new in vitro system provides a convenient tool to analyze in situ the mechanisms underlying different developmental pathways during the microspore reprogramming, breaking or not the cellular symmetry, the establishment of polarity and the developmental embryo patterning, which further produce mature embryos and plants.
In recent years, microspore culture for doubled haploids (DH) has become a routine biotechnological tool for value addition in crops and several successful DH protocols that can fast track traditional or modern plant breeding approaches have been described in Brassicas[1, 2]. Rapeseed (Brassica napus L.), is considered as one of the model systems for studying microspore embryogenesis. Isolated microspore in-vitro cultures provide a unique opportunity to study the cellular events that mark reprogramming and totipotency at single cell level. In B. napus ever since the first report of embryogenesis induction in anther culture using a heat shock treatment , the use of a high temperature treatment i.e. 32°C for 3-21d, is accepted as the norm for developing microspore derived embryos both in cultured anthers and microspores (Charne and Beversdorf 1988, ( [4–8]). Apart from this, culture of isolated microspores of B. napus at 18°C has been proposed as an ideal system to study the gametophytic development in-vitro, wherein cultures with tricellular pollen (up to 90% viable) can be obtained after eight days of culture [9, 10]. Recently Joosen and co-workers  have presented a comparative transcriptome and proteome analysis that identifies the two in vitro developmental pathways, embryogenic or gametophytic. They also reported a new in vitro system to obtain microspore embryos by a short 24 h incubation of isolated microspores to 32°C with the predominance of the suspensor throughout their development. These new developmental features in B. napus microspore embryogenesis have been further described in detail .
Previous results from anther/ microspore cultures of other horticultural herbaceous and woody species have also established that the application of a heat shock treatment (32-33°C) during the vacuolated phase efficiently induced microspores reprogramming to embryogenesis [13–18].
In plants, asymmetric cell division is essential in many developmental processes to maintain cell diversity and tissue patterns, as well as to generate new cell fates throughout development (reviewed in ). The breaking of symmetry is regulated by intrinsic and extrinsic factors determining the polarity in equally or unequally dividing cells . The occurrence and relevance of asymmetric divisions have been studied in different plant developmental processes, as zygotic embryogenesis. Nevertheless, it has not been analyzed during microspore embryogenesis yet.
The cellular architecture specific changes that occur during the switch from gametophytic to embryogenic pathway following a heat shock treatment in B. napus have been reported earlier [10, 21–25], however, in all these studies related to developmental fate of the microspore, most emphasis has been laid on the early stages of embryo development whereas the later fate of microspore embryos in terms of their germination, ploidy assessment and establishment of mature seed bearing plants has not been reported. In any alternate system of microspore embryos production, the efficiency in regenerating DH plants is essential to evaluate the physiological status of the microspore embryos produced by any pathway, and to assess the system as a breeding tool.
In the present work, a new in vitro system in which microspore embryogenesis was efficiently induced in Brassica napus at low temperature has been developed. Under 18°C treatment, the reprogrammed microspores followed two different developmental pathways to form embryos, the major pathway involving the formation of suspensor-like structures, and the minor pathway producing multicellular embryos without suspensor; additionally, a proportion of non-responsive microspores were able to follow a gametophytic-like development leading to mature pollen. Defined conditions for donor plant growth under low temperature that positively affect the efficiency of microspore embryogenesis were also determined. In addition, a new strategy for germination of microspore embryos was developed to achieve more than 90% conversion of embryos to plantlets. This new system provides an interesting in vitro tool for analyzing the cellular processes underlying the different developmental pathways taking place at early microspore reprogramming and embryogenesis leading to mature embryos and plants.
Material and methods
Plant material, donor plant growth conditions and microspore stage analysis
The donor plants of Brassica napus genotype Topas were grown in two distinct growth conditions. Seeds of donor plants were sown in 15cm plastic pots containing agropeat (Campo®, CAMPO Agricultura, Barcelona, Spain) and these were grown in a growth chamber maintained at 18°C/ 16 h photoperiod with light intensity (100 μmol m-2 s-1) and 60% relative humidity (RH) till crown initiation. Thereafter, the plants were shifted to two different growth conditions; (1) growth chamber (Sanyo MLR-351) maintained at 15°C day, 16 h photoperiod (190 μmol m-2 s-1),10°C night, 60 ± 5% RH) and (2) greenhouse at 18°C day/ night with ambient photoperiod and RH. Under both donor plant conditions, flower buds were collected within 2 h from start of photoperiod for microspore stage evaluation and subsequent isolation for culture. To establish the relationship between bud size and microspore stage of development, immediately after collection, the buds were graded into four bud sizes ranging from 3.0 to 3.9 mm (equal intervals of 0.2 mm) measured from the base to the tip of the bud. Sample preparation for fluorescence microscopy was done as per  with modifications. In order to derive a quantitative estimation, 10–12 buds of each bud size range were macerated in 3 ml of 10% (w/v) sucrose solution and the slurry was filtered through a 48μm nylon filter. The filtrate was centrifuged at 2000 rpm for 5 min at room temperature and after decanting the supernatant, the pelleted microspores were stained with 50 μL 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) solution [6 μg/ml in phosphate buffered saline (PBS)] and incubated for 2 h at room temperature. Slide preparations were observed under UV fluorescence using Zeiss Axioplan epifluorescence microscope equipped with a CCD camera. The cell counts were taken for different stages of microspores at 20 × magnification from 3–4 different fields from each slide. The three replicate percentage data for microspores from buds coming from the two donor growth conditions and four bud size categories was arcsine transformed and analysed by 2 × 4 factorial ANOVA . Isolated microspores from different growth conditions and bud size categories were also fixed in paraformaldehyde and processed as per  for bioimaging analysis as detailed below. Microspore cultures were carried out for over two years and four passages of new donor plants in each growth condition.
Microspore isolation and culture
The effect of temperature treatments on microspore embryogenesis for induction was tested using the donor plants grown above under two growth environment. The experiment was planned in a three replicate 2 × 3 factorial completely randomized design (CRD) wherein microspores were isolated from buds harvested from the two growth environments and subjected in-vitro to three different temperature conditions. Each replicate of the experiment consisted of at least two separate isolations events. The procedure described by Prem et al.  was followed for microspore isolations with minor modifications. Flower buds were graded according to size and predominance of vacuolated microspore stage. The selected buds were surface-sterilized in 5.0% (v/v) commercial bleach (5% active chlorine) for 20 min and then rinsed 6–7 times with sterile distilled water. Ten to 15 buds were crushed using a cold mortar and pestle in 5 ml of cold NLN-13 medium (; Duchefa) containing 13% sucrose (w/v). The suspension was filtered through 48 μm nylon mesh and the filtrate collected in 15-ml falcon centrifuge tubes. The crushed buds were rinsed with 5 ml NLN-13 to make up the volume to 10 ml and the filtrate was then centrifuged at 1100 rpm for 5 min at 4°C. The pellet was re-suspended in 10 ml of cold NLN-13 and centrifuged as mentioned above. This process was repeated three times for washing of the microspores. The final pellet was suspended in the NLN-13, and the cell density was adjusted to 10,000 cells per ml. The cell suspension was then poured into 60-mm Petri dishes (2.5-3 ml per Petri dish). After isolation, cultures were subjected to three different temperature conditions in dark, namely, 32.0 ± 1°C, 18 ± 1°C and 25 ± 1°C (control) and checked every 2d under stereomicroscope till development of globular/ heart shaped embryos was observed. Thereafter, cultures were shifted to 25 ± 1°C on a gyratory shaker at 60 rpm until complete development and maturation of the embryos was observed, around 30 days for the system induced at 32°C, and 40 days for the new system at 18°C. Results were quantified in terms of number of embryos produced per Petri dish and quantitative analysis for embryogenic response was done by partitioning the overall experimental variation using 2 × 3 factorial ANOVA , while qualitative cell architecture analysis was carried out by bioimaging at various stages of microspore culture.
Processing and staining techniques for microscopic analysis
The microspore cultures were monitored by bright field and phase contrast microscopy using an in vivo live cell imaging microscope (Leica AF6000 LX with Electron multiplier CCD camera Hamamatsu C9100-02). Samples from cultures were also analysed for observing cell division patterns using DAPI (6 μg/ml) squash preparations as described by Solis et al. . Based on in-vivo live imaging and DAPI analysis, samples of cultured microspores, multicellular pro-embryos and embryo at different developmental stages from different experimental treatments, were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS, overnight, at 4°C. They were embedded in gelatin and processed as per Solis et al. . Selected samples were dehydrated in acetone series and embedded in Technovit 8100 resin (Kulzer, Germany) at 4°C. Some semi-thin sections (1 μm) were stained with toluidine blue (0.075% toluidine blue in water) for structural analysis . After washing and drying, sections were mounted in Eukitt and observed under bright field. DAPI staining (6 μg/ml) was used for observing nuclear components under UV irradiation in squash preparations.
For detection of dead cells, Evan’s blue staining was directly performed on culture samples as reported previously . All slide preparations were observed with a Zeiss Axioplan epifluorescence microscope equipped with a CCD camera.
Immunofluorescence for auxin localization
Semithin Historesin sections were incubated with 5% bovine serum albumin (BSA) in PBS for 5 minutes and then with anti-indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) mouse monoclonal antibodies (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA) diluted 1/100 in 0.1% BSA for 1 h at room temperature. After washing in PBS three times, 5 min each wash, the signal was revealed with ALEXA 488 (green fluorescence) conjugated anti-mouse antibodies (Molecular Probes, Eugene, Oregon, USA), diluted 1:25 in PBS for 45 min in the dark. After washing in PBS, the sections were counterstained with DAPI, mounted in Mowiol and observed in a confocal microscope. Confocal optical sections were collected using Leica TCS SP2 confocal scanning. Controls were performed by replacing the first antibody with PBS.
Embryo conversion to plantlets: embryo germination
The procedure described by Prem et al.  was followed for in-vitro embryo conversion to plantlets (germination). Only microspore embryos originated from donor plants of low temperature growth chambers were used. MS media  containing 2% sucrose (w/v) gelled with 7 g/L bacteriological agar (w/v) was used for embryo germination. The effect of embryo induction temperature, desiccation treatment and incubation temperature for germination was tested in a four replicate 2 × 2 × 3 factorial CRD (embryos resulting from two different inductive temperatures × two desiccation treatments –slow air drying on sterile filter paper before incubation on germination media or direct incubation on germination media without air drying × three incubation temperatures for germination- 4°C for 10d in dark or 18°C in dark till activation of radicle and plumule or 25°C, 16 h photoperiod). The response was quantified after 15-20d of incubation in terms of percentage of embryos showing normal growth similar to zygotic embryo germination. The percentage data was arcsine transformed and analysed by 2 × 2 × 3 factorial ANOVA .
Ploidy assessment by flow cytometry
The 3–4 leaf growth stage plantlets developed 25-30d after incubation on induction media were used for ploidy analysis using high throughput flow cytometry. Sample preparation buffer proposed by  was used for isolation of nuclei from young leaf samples. Leaf segments (7-10 mm diameter) were finely chopped using a sterile surgical blade in 1000 μL sample preparation buffer. The sample was then filtered using a 25 mm Swinnex® filter holder (Millipore) fitted with a double layer of 48 μM nylon filter and the final volume of the filtrate was adjusted to 700 μL with buffer. Thereafter, 70 μl Propidium Iodide (PI- 1.0 mg/ ml prepared in PBS) was added to the filtrate immediately followed by 0.75 μL RNase. The samples were incubated at room temperature for 10 min in dark and then analysed by a Becman Coulter FC500 flow cytometer equipped with an argon ion laser tuned at excitation λ = 488 nm and specific fluorescence signals were collected by 620 bp filter. The percentage data for ploidy level analysis for plantlets originating from microspore embryos induced at different temperature treatments was compared by two tailed t-test assuming unequal variance .
Hardening and transplanting for haploid and doubled-haploid (DH) plant production
Following flow cytometric analysis, plantlets were hardened and transferred to pots in greenhouse (same conditions as for donor plants) following the procedure described by Prem et al. . Observations were recorded for percentage of survival during the hardening and final realization of pod/ seed bearing plants to determine the overall efficiency of the DH protocol. The mean survival frequency of plants with different ploidy level was compared by two tailed t-test assuming unequal variance . Throughout the manuscript data has been presented as means ± Standard Error (mean) and means represented by the same letter are not significantly different according to the stated criterion of comparison.
Effect of growth temperature of donor plant and in vitro temperature treatments on triggering microspore embryogenesis
Microspore developmental stage and their structural organization at cellular level was analyzed (Additional file 1) in flower buds of different sizes. Buds containing the maximum proportion of vacuolated microspores, the most responsive stage for embryogenesis induction, were identified by DAPI-stained squash preparations of microspores (Additional file 1) and selected for in vitro purposes.
The effect of plant growth conditions and culture temperature treatment was studied in a two-fold experiment wherein microspores were collected from donor plants grown under two different environmental conditions (greenhouse at 18°C and growth chamber at 15°C day/10°C night) and isolated microspores were subjected to three temperature treatments 32°C, 25°C and 18°C. The cultures maintained at 25 ± 1°C did not result in any embryo induction (observations up to 40d), therefore this temperature was not considered for statistics. However, microspore embryogenesis was observed from Petri dishes cultured at 32.0 ± 1°C and 18 ± 1°C. Statistical analysis with factorial ANOVA was done for the 2 × 2 factors (two donor growth conditions and two in vitro temperature treatments). Both these factors had a significant effect on microspore embryogenesis, quantified in terms of number of embryos produced per Petri dish, as demonstrated by the ANOVA test which showed that the contribution of the two factors were statistically significant (Additional file 2). The embryo induction (Figure 1) was on an average, four times higher from microspores subjected to 32.0 ± 1 C (733.1 ± 149.6a embryos/ Petri dish) compared to 18.0 ± 1°C (178.2 ± 68.0b embryos/ Petri dish), irrespective of the donor plant growth condition (Figure 1). On the other hand, microspores obtained from plants grown under completely controlled environment in the growth chamber at low temperatures (15°C day/10°C night) showed seven times higher embryogenic ability (795.8 ± 146.4a embryos/ Petri dish) compared to those obtained from greenhouse (115.4 ± 20.7b embryos/ Petri dish) irrespective of the in vitro temperature treatment (Figure 1), therefore, in further analysis, only microspore cultures from donor plants of low temperature growth chambers were used. The highest embryogenesis response was recorded from microspores obtained from growth chamber donor plants and subjected in vitro to 32.0 ± 1°C (1281.1 ± 98.9 embryos/ Petri dish). Figure 2A and B show the comparison of embryo induction at different in vitro temperatures from donor plants grown under different conditions. At both in vitro temperatures, the mature microspore embryos showed similar morphology, characterised by clear differentiation of the cotyledons and radicle end, as shown in Figure 2A (32°C) and 2B (18°C). However, the size of the mature microspore embryos was smaller in Petri dishes subjected to 32°C (Figure 2A) compared to those induced at 18°C (Figure 2B), probably because the higher embryo density in the Petri dish at 32°C resulted in a higher competition for nutrition.
Monitoring cellular organization during microspore embryogenesis induction and embryo development
Early stages of microspore embryogenesis induced at 18 ± 1°C
During the initial 6–8 days of culture at 18°C, the cell population in culture was predominantly composed of large oval cells (Figure 3a) which displayed three nuclei similar to mature pollen, as revealed by DAPI staining, two small nuclei similar in size and fluorescent brightness (sperm like nuclei) and one large nucleus (vegetative like nucleus) with faint fluorescence (Figure 3b). Also, numerous small rounded microspores were observed in the culture (Figure 3a). Many of them were stained when treated with Evan’s blue, specific staining for dead cells (Figure 3c), indicating the existence of a high proportion of dead cells in the culture.
Within the next 13–19 days, the culture was composed of different structures (Figure 4) that could be grouped in three types of developmental programs, together with many small dead microspores (Figure 4, thin arrows). These structures were, a) gametophytic-like cells (Figure 3) that resembled the mature pollen, as described above, b) rounded two-cell and multicellular pro-embryos, many of them surrounded by the microspore wall, the exine (thick arrows in Figures 4 and 5), similar to those of the microspore embryogenesis system induced by continuous 32°C, and c) structures with an uniseriate organized pathway of divisions leading to the development of suspensor-like structures henceforth referred to the suspensor-like pathway (open arrows in Figures 4 and 6).
The cell population of the suspensor-like pathway was highly asynchronous during the 13-19d period, consisting of three main types of structures: large single cells with large nucleus, a very thick cell wall surrounded the cell, and ruptured exine (Figure 6a), two-cell pro-embryos with broken exine (Figure 6b, c), and 3–8 cell suspensor-like structures with the exine attached to the original microspore (Figure 6d, e), some of them displaying a distinct proembryo globular head of 4–6 cells at the opposite pole (Figure 6f). The smaller structures of 1–3 cells were mainly observed between the 13-15d,, and larger pro-embryos with suspensor-like structures were predominantly observed between 17-19d.
Differential cellular features between suspensor-like and embryo structures
The microscopic analysis of semithin sections of resin-embedded samples revealed the subcellular organization of the embryo and suspensor-like structures (Figure 7a, d), The suspensor-like structure (Figure 7d) was formed by a uniseriate line of cells separated by straight cell walls and containing large central nuclei surrounded by numerous vacuoles separated by thin radial cytoplasmic threads, typical organization of the suspensor cells in early zygotic embryogenesis . Remnants of the exine were observed surrounding the cell localized at one pole of the suspensor structure (Figure 7d). The cells forming the embryo structure at early stages of development displayed polygonal shape and dense cytoplasms (Figure 7a). Analogous cellular organization was found in embryos of the other pathway, observed as rounded multicellular structures surrounded by the exine and without suspensor (Figure 7g).
In order to analyze characteristic differential features of embryo and suspensor cells in the structures developed in the cultures, intracellular localization of endogenous auxin was studied by immunofluorescence with specific anti-IAA antibodies. Confocal microscopy analysis showed a low IAA signal in the suspensor-like cells (Figure 7e, f) while an intense IAA fluorescence was observed in the embryo cells (Figure 7b, c), indicating a differential localization of endogenous auxins between suspensor-like and embryo cells at this early developmental stage, being the auxin concentrated in the embryo, as occurs in zygotic embryogenesis. Multicellular embryos surrounded by exine also showed high and homogeneous IAA localization (Figure 7h, i),
Quantitative analysis of developing structures at early stages in microspore cultures at 18°C
In order to analyze the cell population dynamics in the three different developmental pathways observed, a quantitative analysis of the different structures present in the cultures was carried in cultures at 13-19d using DAPI stained preparations, eliminating the dead cells of the analysis. The results (Figure 8) showed a large predominance of the suspensor-like pathway (52.4%) over the other two pathways, the gametophytic-like pathway (34.4%), and the embryogenesis pathway without suspensor, similar to that usually found under 32°C (13.1%). The percentage of the different structures of each developmental pathway was also evaluated and is schematically represented in Figure 9.
Late microspore embryos development at 18 ± 1°C
At 20-24d, two types of multicellular embryos were observed: small globular pro-embryos without suspensor and proembryos formed by a distinct globular head of 6–8 cells and an uniseriate suspensor-like structure with 8–10 cells. During the next 26-30d, embryos displayed a much larger globular head composed of cells which had divided in various directions (Figure 10). In most of these embryos with suspensor, the remnants of the exine were found attached to the filamentous end opposite to the globular head (Figure 10c). The growth and elongation of the suspensor was sustained throughout the late globular to heart shaped stage (Figure 10). Further development produced torpedo embryos which did not show suspensor cells. The mature microspore embryos induced at 18°C were similar to those observed at 32°C, although these developed much later, after 34-40d of culture.
Germination of microspore embryos induced at both temperatures 32°C and 18°C
The embryos induced by the two temperatures (32°C and 18°C), from donor plants grown under low temperature conditions in growth chambers, were tested for their germination ability, under different desiccation treatments (slow air desiccation or direct culture without desiccation) and different temperature conditions (4°C for 10d, 18°C up to activation of radicle–plumule, and 25°C continuously). The results of this experiment were quantified in terms of percentage of direct germination (Table 1) and a 2 × 2 × 3 ANOVA test was applied to elucidate interaction among factors (Additional file 3). While no statically significant difference was observed between the germination response of embryos induced under 32°C and 18°C treatments, the desiccation treatment and the temperature for germination had a significant influence on germination (Additional file 3). The quantitative analysis of embryo germination (Table 1) showed that slow air desiccation resulted in more than three times higher (50.3 ± 19.8%) embryo germination percentage compared to direct culture of embryos (14.0 ± 4.7%), irrespective of the embryo induction temperature and conditions for incubation. The optimum frequency of embryo germination (86.5 ± 3.7%) was obtained by slow air desiccation of embryos followed by their culture at 18.0 ± 1°C in dark conditions till activation of radicle and plumule (Table 1). Under these conditions, the plumule (cotyledons) end of embryos turned yellow and visible development of radicle was observed (Figure 11a), within 20-24d of culture in germination media. These embryos were then shifted to 25.0 ± 1°C, 16 h photoperiod conditions where chlorophyll activation occurred within the following 7-10d of culture (Figure 11b). Three-four true leaf stage plantlets were obtained after about 24-28d (Figure 11c) and leaf disk segments from these plantlets were used for flow cytometry to analyse ploidy level and haploid/spontaneous doubled haploid plantlets were labelled before further growth.
Conversion of microspore-derived plantlets to mature seed bearing plants
The three-four leaf stage plantlets were further sub-cultured in tubes and further leaf development and shoot elongation was observed in the following 20-21d of sub-culture (Figure 11d). At this stage, plantlets were subsequently transferred to glass jars containing agropeat with half-strength MS media without sucrose for acclimatisation/hardening. Under these conditions, within the next 21-30d, shoot elongation, multiplication of leaves (15–20 leaves) and visible root growth was observed. Such photoautotrophic plantlets were subsequently transferred to plastic pots (Figure 11e) and grown in a growth chamber as described for donor plants. Subsequently, the plants were shifted to greenhouse after crown initiation (Figure 11f). A total of 86 plants were transferred to greenhouse and high survival frequency ranging from 96.4 to 98.0% was recorded, irrespective of their ploidy status, up to the flowering stage (Figure 11g).
Ploidy level of plantlets regenerated from microspore derived embryos
The plantlets regenerated from microspore embryos obtained from the two different temperature conditions were analysed for ploidy level by flow cytometry, standarizing a novel method of nuclei isolation which resulted in high fidelity separation of nuclei. Flow charts generated from diploid controls (from a donor plant), haploid and spontaneous doubled haploid plants from microspore embryos were obtained (Figure 12) and quantified A percentage of 63.9 ± 9.9% of the regenerated plants were spontaneous doubled haploid irrespective of the induction temperature used (Table 2). Embryos obtained at 18°C produced a higher percentage of haploid plants (41.3 ± 6.5%) than the embryos induced at 32°C (33.3 ± 13.3%). No statistical difference was observed for recovery of spontaneous doubled haploids from microspore embryos derived from 18.0 ± 1°C and 32.0 ± 1°C (Table 2). The quantification of the efficiency of hardening and plant growth till flowering of haploid and doubled-haploid plants is shown in Table 3. After transfer to greenhouse and further growth, most regenerated plants reached the flowering stage and, among them, the spontaneous diploids had similar hardening survival (96.1 ± 3.8%) compared to the haploid plants (91.6 ± 1.6%).
Donor plant growth at low temperatures significantly improves yield of microspore embryogenesis
Several studies have shown the influence of donor growth environment on microspore totipotency [34–38]. The reasons why the microspores in the same stage of development obtained from different growth environment react in different ways to the same stimulus still remain largely unknown. Donor plant growth in controlled environment specially subjected to low temperature, as in the present study, have been reported to have a slower metabolic rate compared to partially controlled/ field grown donors, due to altered endogenous levels of growth regulators and nutrient utilization of anthers and microspores .
Our results showed a better embryogenic response of microspores from donor plants grown at low temperatures, Under low temperature the in vivo development of microspores would be slower and therefore, the general asynchrony of microspores inside anthers would be lower, which would favour to collect a more homogeneous population of late vacuolated microspores, exactly in the small developmental window of maximum embryogenic response. On the other hand, during pollen development in vivo, any nutritional reduction or environmental change can affect pollen development and viability. Our results showed that donor plants subjected to strictly controlled low temperature conditions in the growth chambers would contain a higher proportion of microspores at optimum metabolic state and therefore exhibit a higher embryogenic response than those from greenhouse donors.
18°C stress treatment efficiently induces microspore embryogenesis through different developmental pathways
In B. napus, isolated microspore development at 18°C has been studied for in vitro gametophytic development [9, 10], however, these reports only illustrated cellular events from the first week up to 10d of culture, until the development of mature pollen-like structures, as observed in the present work. The detailed analysis of long term low temperature incubation of isolated microspores has not been studied as yet. The present results reveal a novel mechanism for microspore embryogenesis induction in B. napus using continuous low temperature stress treatments. Based on our results, the Figure 13 shows the schematic summary of the timing of the different developmental pathways of microspore embryogenesis in the two different temperature treatments, the one at 32°C and the new system at 18°C. The major embryogenesis pathway found under 18°C treatment involves the early polarity establishment and the formation of suspensor-like structures.
The fact that temperature can control the development of isolated microspores in culture has been well documented in B. napus, Lower temperatures favour asymmetric divisions while heat treatments switch symmetric divisions [6, 9, 10]. In the new system developed here, during the first 6–8 days low temperature would promote gametophytic development and an asymmetric division forming vegetative and generative-like cells, whereas at longer periods low temperature favours an embryogenesis pathway whose first division originates asymmetric cell identities.
The new in vitro system, under low temperature, efficiently induced microspore embryogenesis by two different developmental pathways, the major pathway involving the formation of suspensor-like structures, and the minor pathway producing embryos without suspensor, similar to the development usually found under 32°C. The embryogenesis efficiency of the new system at 18°C was high, but lower than that at 32°C. This quantitative difference between both systems could be due to the proportion of microspores following the gametophytic-like pathway, not present at 32°C, together with the cell death occurring in the first days. The variation observed in embryo size would be related to the number of embryos produced per Petri dish at both temperatures, 32°C and 18°C, and could be due to in vitro competition for nutrition. Similar morphological variation in microspore embryos has been reported for B. napus and B. juncea.
One interesting feature found in the microspores following the suspensor-like pathway was the formation of a thick cell wall under the exine which was observed at very early stages, in the embryogenic microspores with large size and ruptured exine. Changes in the inner wall of the microspore have been reported after embryogenesis induction in different systems [16–18]. These special cell walls of embryogenic microspores usually showed an increased thickness with respect to the original microspore wall, therefore being suggested as embryogenic markers [16–18]. The observation of a thick inner wall in the large microspores with broken exine under 18°C, constitutes an additional evidence supporting the embryogenic nature of these microspores.
A microspore embryogenesis pathway occurring at 18°C involves early polarity establishment and suspensor development, mimicking zygotic embryogenesis initials
During zygotic embryo development in B. napus, the polarity of developing embryo is established at the first cell division and the suspensor develops from very early stages showing 6–8 cells at the octant phase of the embryo proper [33, 41, 42]. Several reports have emphasized on the similarity of zygotic and microspore embryogenesis during later stages, e.g. from globular embryos and further development [16, 17, 33, 42, 43]. In the new system reported here, the most striking similarity between the zygotic and microspore embryogenesis was the occurrence of suspensor-like cells at very early stages. The occurrence of suspensor-like cells has been reported as sporadic and unpredictable after a 32°C treatment, only at later stages, in microspore globular and heart embryos. [33, 42]. It had been proposed that the suspensor-like cells which appear in globular-microspore embryos induced at 32°C develop from hypophysal-like cells of the globular embryo [33, 42, 44]. More recently, Joosen et al.  have reported the development of a novel method of microspore cultures, induced by a 24 h, 32°C heat shock which lead to embryo development that closely resembles zygotic embryogenesis. Further, Supena et al.  have reported the detail of this zygotic-embryo-like pathway. Our results revealed the occurrence of a predominant suspensor-like pathway under a different temperature treatment, 18°C; in this pathway, the first divisions of the microspore would originate an elongated structure from which the distal part generates a globular embryo proper while the lower part resembles a suspensor, establishing an early polarity in the microspore embryos development and mimicking zygotic embryogenesis at very early stages. Our results revealed that the cells forming these two parts of the microspore-derived structures displayed different cellular organization and IAA concentration, similar to suspensor and embryo cells [33, 45], therefore confirming their different cell type and fate. Endogenous auxin concentration was also found in multicellular embryos surrounded by exine and without suspensor, indicating that auxin is present in microspore-derived embryo cells, independently of the pathway followed. In the zygotic embryogenesis, following the initial asymmetric zygote division, the identities and cell division patterns of the basal and apical cells, which will form the suspensor and embryo proper respectively, are determined by differential expression of some transcription factors and proteins (reviewed in ). In the new suspensor-like microspore embryogenesis pathway, the first division formed two equally sized daughter cells which could led to asymmetric cell identities, as in other plant processes in which different cell fates are determined in equally sized daughter cells by polar localization of inner and external signals [19, 20]. The detection of a higher concentration of endogenous IAA in the embryo cells in comparison with the suspensor, as reported here, suggests that an early auxin gradient could be one of the inner signals which would contribute to the identity specification of suspensor and embryo cells in this microspore embryogenesis system, like in zygotic embryogenesis [45, 46].
The mechanisms breaking the symmetry of cell division  would not act in the reprogrammed microspores which did not develop suspensors. In zygotic embryogenesis, the absence of specific signals, like MAPKKK-YODA (YDA) or Short Suspensor protein (SSP), in yda and ssp mutants makes zygotes to fail in expand longitudinally, the first zygotic division is symmetric and further divisions occur in random orientation, therefore the suspensor does not develop and embryo develops normally until octant stage . Together with extrinsic factors, there are also evidences for intrinsic factors, mainly transcriptional regulators, which determine differential expression of factors of asymmetric gene expression in two-cell embryos (De-Smet and Beckman ).
The reason why microspores under the same external in vitro conditions showed such different behaviours remains unknown; differences in the initial developmental stage and metabolic state of the microspores could affect the reception of signals to follow different types of developmental programs and for establishment of asymmetric identities and suspensor cell fate specification in some microspores, like it occurs in zygotic embryogenesis . At later stages of development, our report shows the morphological similarity of mature microspore embryos produced from the two inductive treatments (32°C and 18°C), the suspensor is not more found at later stages in any in vitro system, indicating its role at early stages. This new in vitro system represents an advantage for a comparative study of the mechanisms of both embryogenesis pathways, since it permits to analyze different cellular dynamics at the same conditions of induction, studies that would shed light on the molecular mechanisms underlying microspore reprogramming to embryogenesis and the establishment of polarity and developmental embryo patterning.
High efficiency in microspore embryo germination and haploid/doubled-haploid plant regeneration achieved by a new in vitro system
In the present work, the development of a novel protocol for high frequency microspore embryo conversion to mature seed bearing plants has been achieved. Controlled air desiccation and low temperature shock has been reported for increasing embryo germination frequency in B. napus[40, 48, 49]. Cold shock of embryos has been reported to enhance germination frequency of microspore embryos up to 90% , however, the plantlet development frequency remains up to 50-58% [50, 51]. Desiccation of microspore embryos with or without pre-treatment with abscisic acid (ABA; 50 μM) has been reported to enhance conversion frequency in B. napus[40, 52]. Embryo drying has a significant role in regulating endogenous ABA levels that affect the maturation and conversion processes . In our study, a combination of air desiccation followed by incubation of mature microspore embryos at 18°C in dark resulted in more than 90% germination frequency; this treatment for germination of microspore embryos has not been reported in B. napus doubled-haploid (DH) systems. Moreover, the overall efficiency of the hardening and transplanting achieved by us was higher than 95% for both haploid and spontaneous DH plants. On the other hand, our results also prove the physiological similarity between the microspore embryos produced by two different induction systems (32°C and 18°C). The reports cited above specifically comparing microspore embryogenesis and zygotic embryo development, only highlight the morphological similarities and did not detail physiological equivalence in terms of embryo germination capability, as our present work revealed.
The present work reveals a novel mechanism for efficient microspore embryogenesis induction in B. napus using continuous low temperature treatment. Results indicated that low temperature applied for longer periods favours an embryogenesis pathway whose first division originates asymmetric cell identities, early polarity establishment and the formation of suspensor-like structures, mimicking zygotic embryogenesis. The new in vitro system reported here provides a convenient tool to analyze in situ the mechanisms underlying different developmental pathways during the microspore reprogramming, breaking or not the cellular symmetry, the establishment of polarity and the developmental embryo patterning, which further produce mature embryos and plants.
Completely randomized design
- MS media:
Murashige and skoog medium
Differential interference contrast.
Prem D, Gupta K, Agnihotri A: Haploidy in crop brassicas: retrospect & prospects. Recent advances in Plant tissue culture & its applications. Edited by: Kumar ASN. New Delhi: I. K. International Private Limited; 2009: 155-186.
Ferrie AMR, Möllers C: Haploids and doubled haploids in Brassica spp. for genetic and genomic research. Plant Cell. Tissue and Organ Culture. 2011, 104: 375-386. 10.1007/s11240-010-9831-4.
Lichter R: Induction of haploid plants from isolated pollen of Brassica napus. Zeitschrift Fur Pflanzenphysiologie. 1982, 105: 427-434.
Pechan PM, Keller WA: Induction of microspore embryogenesis in Brassica napus L. by gamma irradiation and ethanol stress. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol Anim. 1989, 25: 1073-1074. 10.1007/BF02624144.
Yeung E: The Canola microspore-derived embryo as a model system to study developmental processes in plants. Journal of Plant Biology. 2002, 45: 119-133. 10.1007/BF03030304.
Seguí-Simarro JM, Testillano PS, Risueño MC: Hsp70 and Hsp90 change their expression and subcellular localization after microspore embryogenesis induction in Brassica napus L. J Struct Biol. 2003, 142: 379-391. 10.1016/S1047-8477(03)00067-4.
Seguí-Simarro JM, Testillano PS, Jouannic S, Henry Y, Risueño MC: Mitogen-activated protein kinases are developmentally regulated during stress-induced microspore embryogenesis in Brassica napus L. Histochem Cell Biol. 2005, 123: 541-551. 10.1007/s00418-004-0749-y.
Ferrie AMR, Caswell KL: Isolated microspore culture techniques and recent progress for haploid and doubled haploid plant production. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture. 2011, 104: 301-309. 10.1007/s11240-010-9800-y.
Custers JBM, Cordewener JHG, Nollen Y, Dons HJM, Van LookerenCampagne MM: Temperature controls both gametophytic and sporophytic development in microspore cultures of Brassica napus. Plant Cell Rep. 1994, 13: 267-271.
Satpute GK, Long H, Segui-Simarro JM, Risueno MC, Testillano PS: Cell architecture during gametophytic and embryogenic microspore development in Brassica napus L. Acta Physiologiae Plantarum. 2005, 27: 665-674. 10.1007/s11738-005-0070-y.
Joosen R, Cordewener J, Supena EDJ, Vorst O, Lammers M, Maliepaard C, Zeilmaker T, Miki B, America T, Custers J, Boutilier K: Combined transcriptome and proteome analysis identifies pathways and markers associated with the establishment of rapeseed microspore-derived embryo development. Plant Physiol. 2007, 144: 155-172. 10.1104/pp.107.098723.
Supena EDJ, Winarto B, Riksen T, Dubas E, Van Lammeren A, Offringa R, Boutilier K, Custers J: Regeneration of zygotic-like microspore-derived embryos suggests an important role for the suspensor in early embryo patterning. J Exp Bot. 2008, 59: 803-814. 10.1093/jxb/erm358.
Germáná MA: Anther culture for haploid and doubled haploid production. Plant Cell Tissue and Organ Culture. 2011, 104: 283-300. 10.1007/s11240-010-9852-z.
Germana MA: Anther culture for haploid and doubled haploid production. Plant Cell Tissue and Organ Culture. 2011, 104: 283-300. 10.1007/s11240-010-9852-z.
Germáná MA, Chiancone B, Padoan D, Bárány I, Risueño MC, Testillano PS: First stages of microspore reprogramming to embryogenesis through anther culture in Prunus armeniaca L. Environmental and Experimental Botany. 2011, 71: 152-157. 10.1016/j.envexpbot.2010.11.011.
Barany I, Gonzalez-Melendi P, Fadon B, Mityko J, Risueño MC, Testillano PS: Microspore-derived embryogenesis in pepper (Capsicum annuum L.): subcellular rearrangements through development. Biol Cell. 2005, 97: 709-722. 10.1042/BC20040142.
Barany I, Fadon B, Risueno MC, Risueño PS: Cell wall components and pectin esterification levels as markers of proliferation and differentiation events during pollen development and pollen embryogenesis in Capsicum annuum L. Journal of Experimental Botanyt. 2010, 61: 1159-1175. 10.1093/jxb/erp392.
Solís MT, Pintos B, Prado MJ, Bueno MA, Raska I, Risueño MC, Testillano PS: Early markers of in vitro microspore reprogramming to embryogenesis in olive (Olea europaea L.). Plant Sci. 2008, 174: 597-605. 10.1016/j.plantsci.2008.03.014.
De-Smet I, Beeckman T: Asymmetric cell division in land plants and algae: the driving force for differentiation. Nature reviews. Molecular Cell Biology. 2011, 12: 177-189.
Petricka JJ, Van-Norman JM: Cold Spring Harbor Perspectivism Biology. 2009, 1: a000497-10.1101/cshperspect.a000497.
Zaki AM, Dickinson HG: Structural changes during the first divisions of embryos resulting from anther and free microspore culture in B.napus. Protoplasma. 1990, 156: 149-162. 10.1007/BF01560653.
Testillano PS, González-Melendi P, Coronado MJ, Seguí-Simarro JM, Moreno-Risueño MA, Risueno MC: Differentiating plant cells switched to proliferation remodel the functional organization of nuclear domains. Cytogenet Genome Res. 2005, 109: 166-174. 10.1159/000082396.
Seguí-Simarro JM, Barany I, Suarez R, Fadón B, Testillano P, Risueño MC: Nuclear bodies domain changes with microspore reprogramming to embryogenesis. Eur J Histochem. 2006, 50: 35-44.
Seguí-Simarro JM, Corral-Martínez P, Corredor E, Raska I, Testillano PS, Risueño MC: A change of developmental program induces the re-modeling of the interchromatin domain during microspore embryogenesis in Brassica napus L. J Plant Physiol. 2011, 168: 746-757. 10.1016/j.jplph.2010.10.014.
Testillano PS, Risueño MC: Tracking gene and protein expression during microspore embryogenesis by Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopy. Advances in Haploid Production in Higher Plant. Edited by: Touraev A, Forster BP, Mohan Jain S. UK: Springer Science and Bussines Media B.V; 2009, 339-347.
Prem D, Gupta K, Agnihotri A: Effect of various exogenous and endogenous factors on microspore embryogenesis in Indian mustard. [Brassica juncea (L.) Czern and Coss]. In Vitro Cellular and Developmental Biology - Plant. 2005, 41: 266-273. 10.1079/IVP2005636.
Gómez K, Gómez A: Statistical Procedures for Agriculture Research.John Willey and Sons:IRRI publication, New York; 1984.
Rodríguez-Serrano M, Bárány I, Prem D, Coronado MJ, Risueño MC, Testillano PS: NO, ROS and cell death associated with caspase-like activity increase in stress-induced microspore embryogenesis of barley. J Exp Bot. 2011, 63: 2007-2024.
Prem D, Gupta K, Sarkar G, Agnihotri A: Activated charcoal induced high frequency microspore embryogenesis and efficient doubled haploid production in Brassica juncea. Plant Cell Tissue and Organ Culture. 2008, 93: 269-282. 10.1007/s11240-008-9373-1.
Murashige T, Skoog F: A revised medium for rapid growth and bio assays with tobacco tissue cultures. Physiol Plant. 1962, 15: 473-497. 10.1111/j.1399-3054.1962.tb08052.x.
Wilkinson MJ, Davenport IJ, Charters YM, Jones AE, Allainguillaume J, Butler HT, Mason DC, Raybould AF: A direct regional scale estimate of transgene movement from genetically modified oilseed rape to its wild progenitors. Mol Ecol. 2000, 9: 983-991. 10.1046/j.1365-294x.2000.00986.x.
Sokal R, Rohlf F: Biometry: The principles and practices of statistics in biological research 2nd edition. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company; 1981.
Yeung EC, Rahman MH, Thorpe TA: Comparative development of zygotic and microspore-derived embryos in Brassica napus L cvTopas.1. Histodifferentiation. International Journal of Plant Sciences. 1996, 157: 27-39. 10.1086/297317.
Dunwell JM, Cornish M, Decourcel AGL: Influence of genotype, plant growth temperature and anther incubation temperature on microspore embryo production in Brassica napus sp. oleifera. J Exp Bot. 1985, 36: 679-689. 10.1093/jxb/36.4.679.
Chuong PV, Pauls KP, Beversdorf WD: Effect of donor genotype and bud sampling in microspore culture of Brassica napus. Canadian Journal of Botany. 1988, 66: 1653-1657. 10.1139/b88-225.
Gland A, Lichter R, Schweiger HG: genetic and exogenous factors affecting embryogenesis in isolated microspore cultures of Brassica napus L. J Plant Physiol. 1988, 132: 613-617. 10.1016/S0176-1617(88)80264-5.
Lichter R: Efficient yield of embryoids by culture of isolated microspore of different Brassicaceae species. Plant Breeding. 1989, 103: 119-123. 10.1111/j.1439-0523.1989.tb00359.x.
Takahata Y, Brown DCW, Keller WA: Effect of donor plant age and inflorescence age on microspore culture of Brassica napus L. Euphytica. 1991, 58: 51-55. 10.1007/BF00035339.
Lo KH, Pauls KP: Plant growth environment effects on rapeseed microspore development and culture. Plant Physiol. 1992, 99: 468-472. 10.1104/pp.99.2.468.
Kott LS, Beversdorf WD: Enhanced plant regeneration from microspore-derived embryos of Brassica napus by chilling, partial desiccation and age selection. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Culture. 1990, 23: 187-192.
Raghavan V: Life and times of the suspensor of angiosperm embryos. Trends in Plant Science Phytomorphology Golden Jubilee Issue. 2001, 251-276.
Ilic-Grubor K, Attree SM, Fowke LC: Comparative morphological study of zygotic and microspore-derived embryos of Brassica napus L. as revealed by scanning electron microscopy. Ann Bot. 1998, 82: 157-165. 10.1006/anbo.1998.0661.
Bueno MA, Gómez A, Sepúlveda F, Seguí JM, Testillano PS, Manzanera JA, Risueno MC: Microspore-derived embryos from Quercus suber anthers mimic zygotic embryos and maintain haploidy in long-term anther culture. J Plant Physiol. 2003, 160: 953-960. 10.1078/0176-1617-00800.
Hause B, Van Veenendaal WLH, Hause G, Van Lammeren AAM: Expression of polarity during early development of microspore-derived and zygotic embryos of Brassica napus L. cv. Topas. BotanicaActa. 1994, 107: 407-415.
Möller B, Weijers D: Auxin control of embryo patterning. Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol. 2009, 1: a001545-10.1101/cshperspect.a001545.
Friml J, Vieten A, Sauser M, Weijers D, Schwarz H, Hamann T, Offringa R, Jürgens G: Efflux-dependent auxin gradient establishs the apical-basal axis of Arabidopsis. Nature. 2003, 426: 147-153. 10.1038/nature02085.
Lukowitz W, Roeder A, Parmenter D, Sommerville C: A MAPKK kinase gene regulates extra-embryonic cell fate in Arabidopsis. Cell. 2004, 116: 109-119. 10.1016/S0092-8674(03)01067-5.
Anandarajah K, Kott L, Beversdorf WD, McKersie B: Induction of desiccation tolerance in microspore-derived embryos of Brassica napus L. by thermal stress. Plant Sci. 1991, 77: 119-123. 10.1016/0168-9452(91)90187-D.
Zhang G, Zhang D, Tang G, He Y, Zhou W: Plant development from microspore-derived embryos in oilseed rape as affected by chilling, desiccation and cotyledon excision. Biol Plant. 2006, 50: 180-186. 10.1007/s10535-006-0004-6.
Zhou WJ, Tang GX, Hagberg P: Efficient production of doubled haploid plants by immediate colchicine treatment of isolated microspores in winter Brassica napus. Plant Growth Regulation. 2002, 37: 185-192. 10.1023/A:1020561201125.
Gu HH, Hagberg P, Zhou WJ: Cold pre-treatment enhances microspore embryogenesis in oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.). Plant Growth Regulation. 2004, 42: 137-143.
Senaratna T, Kott L, Beversdorf WD, Mckersie BD: Desiccation of microspore derived embryos of oilseed rape (Brassica rapa L.). Plant Cell Rep. 1991, 10: 342-344.
Kermode AR: Regular mechanisms involved in the transition from seed development to germination. CRC Critical Reviews in Plant Science. 1990, 9: 155-195. 10.1080/07352689009382286.
Work supported by projects granted by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation, MICINN, BFU2008-00203, AGL2008-04255 and BFU2011-23752. DP was recipient of a grant of the Spanish MICINN for Stays of Foreign Postdoctoral Researchers in Spanish Research Centres (SB2006-0074), HRS is recipient of a predoctoral fellowship of the Spanish MICINN (BES-2009-014245).
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
DP performed most of the experimental analyses, the statistics and quantification studies, and wrote the first manuscript draft. MTS had an active contribution to the in vitro assays and performed some microscopic analysis. IB and HR performed the auxin immunofluorescence essays. IB also helped in initial flow cytometry analysis, formatted and prepared several figures. MCR participated in the design and coordination of the work, helped to draft the manuscript and discussed the results. PST designed and coordinated the experimental work, designed and contributed to the draft and wrote most of the manuscript and its revision. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: In vivo microspore gametophytic development in Brassica napus. Developmental stages from donor plants grown under low temperature conditions in growth chambers. Semi-thin sections stained with toluidine blue showing the structural organization of the young microspore (a), vacuolated microspore (b) and bicellular pollen (c). Squash preparations of anthers stained with DAPI and revealing the nuclei of others microspores and pollen at the same developmental stages, young microspore (a’), vacuolated microspore (b’) and bicellular pollen (c’). (PDF 32 kb) (PDF 32 KB)
Additional file 2: Statistical analysis of the contribution of several factors to embryo production in microspore cultures. 2 × 2 factor ANOVA for partitioning variance for microspore embryogenesis response of buds collected from donor plants grown in two different conditions and after isolation, subjected to two different thermal stress conditions (8 replicate data). (PDF 67 kb) (PDF 68 KB)
Additional file 3: Statistical analysis of the contribution of several factors to microspore embryo germination. 2 × 2 × 3 factorial ANOVA for partitioning variation in response of embryo conversion to plantlets (germination) for microspore embryos obtained from two different pathways and from donor plants of growth chambers, cultured directly or air-desiccated and subjected to three different germination pre-treatments. (4 replicate each with 7–20 embryos cultured per replicate for each factor). (PDF 39 kb) (PDF 39 KB)
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Prem, D., Solís, MT., Bárány, I. et al. A new microspore embryogenesis system under low temperature which mimics zygotic embryogenesis initials, expresses auxin and efficiently regenerates doubled-haploid plants in Brassica napus. BMC Plant Biol 12, 127 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2229-12-127