- Research article
- Open Access
Ups and downs of a transcriptional landscape shape iron deficiency associated chlorosis of the maize inbreds B73 and Mo17
BMC Plant Biology volume 13, Article number: 213 (2013)
Improving nutrient homeostasis is a major challenge of a sustainable maize cultivation, and cornerstone to ensure food supply for a growing world population. Although, iron constitutes an important nutrient, iron availability is limited. In this respect, iron deficiency associated chlorosis causes severe yield losses every year. Natural variation of the latter trait has yet not been addressed in maize and was therefore studied in the present analysis.
In this study, we i) report about the contrasting chlorosis phenotypes of the inbreds B73 and Mo17 at 10 and 300 μM iron regime, ii) identified over 400 significantly regulated transcripts (FDR < 0.05) within both inbreds at these growth conditions by deep RNA-Sequencing, iii) linked the gained knowledge with QTL information about iron deficiency related traits within the maize intermated B73 by Mo17 (IBM) population, and iv) highlighted contributing molecular pathways. In this respect, several genes within methionine salvage pathway and phytosiderophore synthesis were found to present constitutively high expression in Mo17, even under sufficient iron supply. Moreover, the same expression pattern could be observed for two putative bHLH transcription factors. In addition, a number of differentially expressed genes showed a co-localisation with QTL confidence intervals for iron deficiency related traits within the IBM population.
Our study highlights differential iron deficiency associated chlorosis between B73 and Mo17 and represents a valuable resource for differentially expressed genes upon iron limitation and chlorosis response. Besides identifying two putative bHLH transcription factors, we propose that methionine salvage pathway and sterol metabolism amongst others; underlie the contrasting iron deficiency related chlorosis phenotype of both inbreds. Altogether, this study emphasizes a contribution of selected genes and pathways on natural trait variation within the IBM population.
Maize is one of the most widely grown crop plants worldwide and has become Africa's most important staple food crop . In regard of a growing world population and the increasing demand for food supply, a sustainable agriculture is of first priority. One topic concerning a sustainable maize cultivation is the improvement of its ability to cope with limiting nutrient supply.
As iron-sensitive crop maize asks for i) investigating the iron deficiency associated chlorosis that different maize genotypes display, ii) identifying the underlying genes and molecular processes, and iii) using this information to improve iron deficiency chlorosis of maize through breeding.
The processes that plants employ to efficiently access iron as well as genotypic variation of iron homeostasis itself are hitherto not completely understood. Knowledge on natural variation of iron deficiency and the chlorosis response is crucial to improve growth of crops in marginal soils, where iron deficiency frequently limits growth. Iron deficiencies are found mainly on calcareous soils  but also develop in acid soils [3, 4]. As iron is involved in the production of chlorophyll, deficiency is easily recognized by the occurrence of chlorosis symptoms, notably yellowish interveinal tissue on the younger upper leaves [3, 5]. Iron constitutes an indispensable plant nutrient and severe deficiencies cause leaves to turn completely yellow or almost white, which in turn strongly impairs plant growth and leads to high yield losses [3, 5]. This furthermore, influences nutritional crop quality and impacts on economic aspects like the need of fertilizers and the accessibility of growth areas.
Upon iron limitation, plants induce a coordinated set of responses that allow maximizing iron mobilization and uptake from the soil. Moreover, internal iron stores are utilized to allocate iron where crucial cellular processes are proceeding. The majority of plants except the grasses use the strategy I response to solubilize and absorb iron into roots when iron is limiting . As result, Fe(III) is converted into Fe(II) and subsequently transported over the plasma membrane into root cells [6, 7]. Maize and the other grasses have adopted another strategy to assimilate iron that relies on the secretion of iron chelators, non-proteinogenic amino acid derivatives, into the rhizosphere that form stable Fe(III) chelates . These Fe(III)/chelator complexes, are then subsequently imported by a specific transporter (YS1) that is located at the root surface [8, 9]. However, the further allocation of iron, its pool sizes and the fluxes within and between cells, tissues or whole organs as well as the regulating mechanisms, which orchestrate iron homeostasis, still remain elusive.
Hitherto, the knowledge on maize iron homeostasis and the involved genes is mainly derived from mutant studies or the molecular genetic analysis of monogenic differences in graminaceous species, such as rice [6, 8, 10–14]. Despite, the considerable number of identified genes and pathways in maize, their contribution to the natural phenotypic variation as well as their impact on modulating environmental adaptation is unknown. The investigation of iron deficiency chlorosis in maize using deep RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) would allow considering the complexity of genotype and treatment related transcriptional differences [15, 16]. In this respect, identified transcriptional differences might either represent causal genes for natural variation of iron mobilization and allocation and the associated chlorosis response in maize or be regulated by the latter. Linkage of the gained information with quantitative trait loci (QTL) studies for iron efficiency related traits in the IBM population (Benke et al., unpublished) allows to pin-point differentially regulated genes that co-localize with QTL confidence intervals and thereby represent excellent candidate genes underlying this trait.
The present study investigates the transcriptomes of the maize inbreds B73 and Mo17, which differ significantly in their chlorosis response upon low iron concentration (10 μM), in order to identify genotype and/or treatment related differentially expressed transcripts. The differences in regulation of these transcripts were further validated by qRT-PCR and the corresponding expression patterns at both, limiting (10 μM) and sufficient (300 μM) iron concentration were integrated in a physiological context. Furthermore, a pathway analysis allowed us to substantiate the impact of specific pathways and related genes onto iron deficiency associated chlorosis. Altogether, the proposed genes present interesting candidates that might contribute to natural variation and could be the basis for further functional analysis and genetic proceedings in diverse natural populations.
Impact of iron regime on the phenotype of the maize inbreds B73 and Mo17
After hydroponic growth at limiting (10 μM Fe) and sufficient iron (300 μM Fe) regime, the maize inbreds B73 and Mo17 were evaluated for the relative chlorophyll content of the 5th and the 6th leaf, determined by measuring SPAD units, as well as length and weight of root and shoot, and the iron content in the shoot. Significant differences between genotypes and treatments were observed (Figure 1). In this respect, Mo17 showed significantly lower SPAD values for the 5th as well as the 6th leaf in comparison to B73. These differences were not only observable at limiting iron concentration but also at sufficient iron supply. All over, B73 showed significantly weaker chlorosis symptoms than Mo17 (Figure 1A, B). Interestingly, absolute root length was higher for Mo17 than for B73 at 300 μM iron. Whereas B73 showed no severe decrease in response to iron limitation, Mo17 root length decreased to even lower values than B73 (Figure 1C). Despite higher root length of Mo17 at 300 μM iron, root weight was drastically lower at both iron regimes when compared to B73 (Figure 1D). Furthermore, B73 was characterized by a significantly larger shoot height as Mo17 at 300 μM iron (Figure 1E). Limiting iron supply led to about equal shoot length values for both genotypes (Figure 1E). Shoot weight was significantly different between the two inbreds at both iron regimes, with B73 having a higher shoot mass than Mo17 (Figure 1F). Finally, the iron content of the shoot was higher for B73 at 300 μM iron than for Mo17 but decreased for both genotypes at similar levels upon limitation (Figure 1G).
In conclusion, B73 was characterized by a more vigorous growth under sufficient iron conditions and lower leaf chlorosis under limiting iron (Figure 1 and Additional file 1: Figure S1A). In addition, B73 samples at 300 μM iron treatment showed highest iron content and biomass trait values, except for root length, which was highest in Mo17 plants at 300 μM iron (Additional file 1: Figure S1A, B). As determined by principal component analysis of trait values, samples of both inbreds at 300 μM iron were followed by samples of B73 and finally Mo17 samples grown at 10 μM iron (Additional file 1: Figure S1B). When comparing growth at 10 versus 300 μM iron, the decrease in trait values was higher for shoot and root traits as well as for iron content of the shoot in B73 than for Mo17. Contrary, the decrease in SPAD values and correspondingly stronger leaf chlorosis was observed in Mo17 than B73 (Additional file 1: Figure S1A).
The iron responsive root transcriptome of B73 and Mo17
Root tissue of two biological replicates was collected at two iron concentrations (10 and 300 μM) in order to determine the differences in the transcriptome of B73 and Mo17. RNA-Seq, resulted in a median library size of 7.6 million reads after quality control (Additional file 1: Table S1). Differentially expressed genes were called in four specific two-way comparisons. The two genotype relative comparisons consisted of analysing the expression profile of root tissue from Mo17 versus tissue from B73 grown at 300 μM (Comparison 1) and at 10 μM iron (Comparison 2). For treatment relative comparisons transcriptome signatures of root tissue from Mo17 (Comparison 3) and B73 (Comparison 4) grown at 10 μM was compared with such resulting from root tissue of the same genotype collected at 300 μM. All log2 fold changes (log2FC) refer to the expression values at condition 1 versus condition 2 (Table 1). In this respect, a positive log2FC in Comparison 1 (Comp. 1) reflects a higher expression in Mo17 grown at 300 μM iron than in B73. Differential expression analysis using four different approaches, namely the cufflinks pipeline with or without RABT  assembly as well as the count table based methods provided by the R packages DeSeq and edgeR yielded a similar number of differentially expressed transcripts (FDR < 0.05). Analysis by DeSeq was most stringent as reflected by the lowest number of transcripts with significant expression differences in two-way comparisons. Interestingly, every detection method resulted in unique transcripts (Additional file 1: Figure S2). Moreover, transcripts significant at an FDR < 0.05 in all four statistical approaches could be identified. Such transcripts were called for each of the four two-way comparisons and constituted the final set of the significantly regulated transcripts that was further investigated. None of these transcripts was shared by all four two-way comparisons (Figure 2). Altogether, 412 unique transcripts were identified as being differentially expressed (FDR < 0.05) in all comparisons, with the highest number of such transcripts in the comparison between Mo17 and B73 at 300 μM (1). Among 376 significantly regulated genes within this comparison, 127 showed a higher expression in Mo17 and a median fold change higher than 2, whilst 244 showed higher expression at the same fold change in B73 (Table 1). The transcriptomic comparison of these two genotypes at 10 μM iron supply yielded 79 significant transcripts, with 31 being more abundant in Mo17 and 48 with higher expression values for B73 (Table 1). Interestingly, only 3 transcripts were detected as differentially expressed at an FDR < 0.05 for the expression profiles of Mo17 grown at 10 μM vs. 300 μM iron (Table 1). The iron deficiency chlorosis resistant genotype B73 induced 13 out of 19 significant genes under iron-limiting conditions. Out of the 19 iron responsive B73 genes, seven showed a differentially expression at non-limiting iron concentration between both genotypes (Table 1 and Figure 2). None of 19 genes was significantly responding to iron starvation in Mo17 (Figure 2). Principal component analysis of transcripts and their expression pattern amongst the four two-way comparisons (Additional file 1: Figure S1C) resulted in a clear sample clustering, separating genotype (PC1) and treatment (PC2). However, clear differentiation of iron treatments was more pronounced for B73 as for Mo17 samples (Additional file 1: Figure S1C).
Significantly regulated transcripts co-localize with relevant trait QTLs
When projecting the final set of significantly regulated on the genetic map, an even distribution across all chromosomes and over their whole length could be observed (Figure 3). Besides, several known candidate genes for iron deficiency repsonse in maize, several of the differentially regulated transcripts located adjacent or within QTL confidence intervals for iron homeostasis in the IBM population (Figure 3, Table 2, Additional file 1: Figure S3). Most of the regulated transcripts were present either in the comparisons of both genotypes in the 300 μM iron regime or when comparing B73 grown at 10 μM to 300 μM iron (Figure 3 and Table 2). The regulated transcripts that mapped to QTLs on maize chromosomes at 300 μM iron, tagged such detected for SPAD values of the 5th and the 6th leaf as well as shoot weight (Table 2). Only a single gene co-localizes with a QTL for shoot length on chromosome I (Table 2). In the case of 10 μM iron regime, the significantly regulated transcripts again co-localized with QTLs for SPAD values of the 5th and 6th leaf, and shoot weight (Table 2). In addition also QTLs for shoot length as well as root weight were tagged. Two transcripts that showed a differential expression between B73 roots harvested at 300 and 10 μM iron mapped to QTL intervals for SP6 at 300 μM iron and SDW at 10 μM, respectively (Table 2).
GO-term enrichment and pathway analysis
A GO-term enrichment analysis of the 412 significantly regulated genes within all two-way comparisons yielded several cellular, biological and functional enriched GOs (Figure 4). In this respect, over-represented cellular component GOs were related to chloroplast, the vacuole and membranous components (Figure 4 and Additional file 1: Table S2). Concerning the GOs related to biological processes, these can be roughly grouped to developmental processes, regulation of cell size, and responses to biotic and abiotic stimulus as well as, nitrogen, sulphur, carboxylic acid and amino acid synthetic related processes (Figure 4 and Additional file 1: Table S2). Especially, methionine and aspartate biosynthetic as well as catabolic process related GOs were overrepresented within the significant gene set. In addition, GOs of response to metal ions, ion homeostasis, anion transport and inorganic anion transport were also found to be enriched. Within the GOs associated with molecular function, oxidoreductase, inorganic anion transport, and phosphatase activity were significantly enriched (P < 0.05).
A pathway analysis showed that significantly regulated genes within the comparison of both genotypes at 300 μM iron supply were involved in amino acid and polyamine metabolism (Additional file 1: Figure S4). Contrary to amino-acid metabolism related transcripts that were induced in Mo17 vs. B73 at non limiting iron supply, expression of polyamine metabolic genes was down-regulated in Mo17 (Additional file 1: Figure S4). Interestingly, transcripts involved in polyamine metabolism were found to be induced in B73 upon iron starvation. In addition, differences were also observed for transport related processes but without a clear trend in respect to genotypic or treatment related comparisons (Additional file 1: Figure S4). Intriguingly, transcripts involved in metal handling processes that were up-regulated in B73 in response to low iron concentration were already present at high expression levels in Mo17 at 300 μM iron (Additional file 1: Figure S4). Interestingly, a custom pathway analysis of phytosiderophore and strategy II iron transport related genes showed differences concerning the expression profile of the significantly regulated gene set for two-way comparisons (Figure 5). Correspondingly, expression of these genes was considerably different at non-limiting iron concentration between Mo17 and B73 (Figure 5). In contrast to B73, showing an induction of genes involved in methionine salvage pathway (YANG pathway) and phytosiderophore synthesis upon iron limitation, Mo17 already expressed these genes at high levels in the 300 μM iron regime (Figure 5).
The polymorphic landscape of Mo17 and B73 and its transcriptional equivalent
In accordance with previous studies , a high degree of polymorphisms between Mo17 and B73 was observed for the majority of chromosomes (Figure 3 and Additional file 1: Figure S5). In addition, conserved genomic regions between both inbreds with low structural variation were identified (Figure 3, Additional file 1: Figure S5) as already described elsewhere . In this respect, an extended region over five arbitrary bins on chromosome VIII (ca. 20 Mbps) was observed (Figure 3, Additional file 1: Figure S5). Remarkably, several strong transcriptional differences were observed in all four two-way comparisons for genes mapping to this region. A high number of polymorphisms could also be detected within the deduced QTL regions for SPAD values of the 5th and the 6th leaf as well as the Fe content in the shoot at both iron concentrations (Additional file 1: Figure S5). In addition, these regions harboured a large number of transcripts, characterized by high median fold changes within the two-way comparisons. The majority of these transcripts were expressed at higher levels in B73 at 300 and 10 μM iron (Additional file 1: Figure S5). Furthermore, these transcripts were induced in B73 at 10 μM and down-regulated in Mo17. The median log2FC of the mapped transcripts declined in the vicinity of the centromere but showed no distinct spatial pattern (Additional file 1: Figure S5).
The validation of differences within the transcriptome of the two maize inbreds B73 and Mo17 by qRT-PCR showed a significant correlation (R2 = 0.77) for a selection of 40 genes (Figure 6 and Additional file 1: Table S4). When focusing on specific candidate genes, divergent expression patterns were observed (Table 3). The selection of candidate genes comprised genes significantly regulated in the comparison of B73 grown at 300 and 10 μM iron, except nicotianamine synthase 1 (NAS1) and formate dehydrogenase (FDH), which were represented by multiple isoform (Additional file 1: Table S3). However, it is noteworthy that NAS1 was found to be represented by two loci (GRMZM2G385200 and GRMZM2G034956), which were significantly regulated in Comp. 4. A further analysis manifested five homologous NAS1 loci in maize that could represent different isoforms arising from duplication events (Additional file 1: Figure S6).
Moreover, the expression level of two putative factors, which showed significant expression differences in Comp. 4 and with high homology to AtPYE/OsIRO3 and OsIRO2 respectively [22, 23], displayed an induction within B73 upon low iron conditions. Interestingly, these genes showed elevated transcript levels in Mo17 independent of the iron regime. Surprisingly, the IRO2 homologuous gene was characterized by a high RNA-Seq read coverage over a length of nearly 20 kb downstream of the putative transcription start site (Figure 7 and Additional file 1: Figure S7). This coverage was significantly lower in Mo17 even though the read counts within the gene model of the reference sequence were comparable to those observed in B73 upon induction. Moreover, several genes encoding putative transporters were significantly regulated in Comp. 3 and 4. It is noteworthy that a putative oligopeptide transporter (GRMZM2G400602) was up-regulated in B73 upon limiting iron in contrast to putative nitrate transporters, which displayed a down-regulation of their expression at 10 μM iron in B73 (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figure S8). In addition, significant genes within the comparison of Mo17 grown at 300 and 10 μM as well as genes at the comparisons of both genotypes at 300 and 10 μM iron showing an experiment wide median P-value within the fourth quartile were included in a further analysis and validation by qRT-PCR. In this respect, a putative NIP-1 homologous aquaporin was amongst the significant genes in Comparison 3 and showed a down-regulation upon limiting iron supply in the RNA-Seq analysis. However, the expression pattern could not be validated for this NIP-1 homologue (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figure S9). Transcripts encoding putative cytochrome P450, known to be involved in secondary metabolism, were up-regulated in Mo17 at 300 and 10 μM iron in comparison to B73 (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figures S7 and S10). Remarkably, a putative obtusifoliol 14-alpha demethylase like gene showed a strong and significant down-regulation in B73 upon limiting iron (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figure S10). As stated above, genes involved in methionine salvage pathway and phytosiderophore synthesis (NAAT and DEP1) were up-regulated in B73 upon low iron regime and already displayed high transcript levels in Mo17 under 300 μM iron (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figure S8). In addition, methylribose-1-phosphate isomerase displays higher expression levels in Mo17 throughout both iron regimes than B73, which again only induces this gene upon iron starvation.
Another interesting finding consists in a transcript encoding a putative BURP-domain protein , which is down-regulated in its expression within B73 at the 10 μM iron regime. This transcript is characterized by a very low expression in Mo17 independent of the applied iron conditions and displays exon-skipping when compared to B73 (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figure S7). Finally, transcripts encoding uncharacterized proteins, O-methyl- and glycosyl-transferases, a dormancy related and auxin responsive gene, a ClpC1 homologue, an enolase, and an aspartic peptidase were validated by qRT (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figures S7, S8, S9 and S10). Pseudogenes, transposable elements and transcripts giving rise to very small peptides (< 50AA) were omitted from a closer analysis.
Phenotypic responses upon iron regime
As outlined above, the maize inbreds B73 and Mo17 showed a contrasting chlorosis response upon limiting iron regime (Figure 1A, B, Additional file 1: Figure S1A, B). Our observations might reflect that Mo17 cannot deal as efficiently as B73 with available iron, even far above limiting concentrations. In addition, the evaluation of the morphological values of shoot and root showed a stronger morphological impact of decreasing iron concentration for Mo17 than for B73 (Figure 1C-F, Additional file 1: Figure S1A, B). These might also be due to an altered iron homeostasis of Mo17, which even at 300 μM tries to maximise iron uptake by increasing root length as well as branching (Benke et al., unpublished). Despite an increase of Mo17 root length, root weight stays significantly lower at both iron treatments, when compared to B73. Correspondingly, the genetic basis of root differences between B73 and Mo17 might influence iron homeostasis and a potential cross-talk between the underlying pathways might exist as shown for Arabidopsis thaliana. If higher biomass of B73 is also a result of a more efficient iron and in general nutrient homeostasis cannot be clearly answered. Interestingly, the iron content in the shoot of both genotypes was not different at limiting iron but lower in Mo17 than in B73 at 300 μM available iron (Figure 1G, Additional file 1: Figure S1A). This in consequence, might indicate that either Mo17 displays a significantly altered iron allocation, a deregulation of iron deficiency signal pathways or impairment in iron store build-up. Although, B73 is characterized by a more vigorous growth under 300 μM treatment, iron content of the shoot was not drastically increased under these conditions. Nevertheless, iron deficiency asscoiated chlorosis is significantly lower for B73 than for Mo17, which might indicate, in addition to other morphological differences, a more efficient iron homeostasis of B73. The nature of the iron deficiency signals, the linked molecular responses, as well as their variation between different genotypes still remain unresolved and should be addressed by further experiments. In this respect, physiological investigations of siderophore production, pool sizes and fluxes as well as of corresponding siderophore/Fe(III)-chelate ratios of a diverse germplasm set might provide answers to these issues.
A transcriptomic compendium of B73 and Mo17 at two different iron regimes
Apart from transcriptional differences a high number of polymorphisms could be detected between both inbreds, which is in concordance to previous studies . Correspondingly, a striking drop in polymorphisms on the long arm of chromosome VIII was observed as previously described  (Figure 3, Additional file 1: Figure S5). In contrast to this study , a considerable number of differentially regulated transcripts has been detected (Figure 3, Additional file 1: Figure S5). The very low level of differential gene expression between B73 and Mo17 in the region on chromosome VIII described by Springer et al., (2009) results from comparative analysis by Affimetrix 17 K microarray data of seedling, embryo and endosperm tissue  without any variation in iron regime. In this respect, the observed strong regulation differences (Figure 3, Additional file 1: Figure S5) in the present study are likely due to the action of trans-acting factors, being polymorphic between B73 and Mo17. Moreover, this emphasizes a putative involvement of regulated transcripts in processes linked to efficient iron homeostasis or stress response in general. The relative low number of polymorphisms between both inbred are likely due to the fact that B73 and Mo17 are identical by descent for this region . However, as recent studies could show that a maize diversity set displays sequence variation in the corresponding chromosome section [25, 27], a selective fixation during the breeding process [28, 29] or a general lack of structural variation in this region seems to be unlikely. Further investigations of this polymorphic  and transcriptional landscape, using a maize diversity set grown at different iron regimes, might provide extended information about genes underlying iron efficiency not only of the IBM population but of maize in general.
Concerning transcriptional differences in the iron responsive signatures of both inbreds, altogether 412 significantly regulated genes over all two-way comparisons could be identified (Figure 2, Table 1, Additional file 1: Table S3). These differences were validated by qRT-PCR for several known [5, 6] as well as novel candidate genes (Table 3). Overall, a highly significant correlation (p < 0.001, R2 = 0.77) was observed (Figure 6), which confirms the quality of the presented transcriptional profiling.
Differentially regulated genes resulted from a combination of the most widely used analytical approaches for the analysis of RNA-Seq data, notably RPKM/FPKM based cufflinks, as well as raw count data based edgeR and DeSeq proceedings. These methods can be divided into two concepts referring to library size (edgeR and DeSeq) or distribution adjustment of read counts (cufflinks) . Both edgeR and DeSeq rely on the hypothesis that most of the genes are not differentially expressed and propose a scaling factor for data normalization . In contrast cufflinks uses library size and gene length normalization . Beside these differences in normalization, determination of differentially expressed genes also relies on slightly different statistical tests. This in consequence results DE genes that are specific for single analysis approaches (Additional file 1: Figure S1). Nevertheless, most significant genes are conserved among the different approaches. DeSeq appears to be most stringent in the determination of DE genes, which might be due to the fact that several transcripts are characterized by low expression and elevated biological variation between biological replicates. These in consequence will be discarded by the DeSeq algorithm. In contrast, edgeR seems to be liberal for lowly expressed genes but compensates for this by being more conservative with strongly expressed genes . Recently, cufflinks and the RPKM normalization, which are still widely used, were described to be ineffective in the context of differential transcriptome analysis and should be abandoned . In contrast, DeSeq and edgeR normalization methods and data analysis were described to be more robust in the presence of different library sizes and widely different library compositions, both of which are typical of real RNA-seq data . Finally, combination of these different, approaches, as presented in this study, offers the possibility to access significant DE genes in single approaches as well as conserved DE genes among all used approaches. In consequence, we propose the use of an experiment wide FDR significance threshold (FDR < 0.05) to unify the results of such a multi statistical transcriptome survey as a robust gene selection criterion. In this respect, the two genotype specific comparisons yielded the highest number of differentially expressed genes (Table 1). Although, the overlap between treatment and genotype comparisons was low seven out of 19 significantly regulated genes within Comparison 4 were also identified as such in Comparison 1 (Figure 2). The low number of significantly regulated genes within Mo17 in the experiment wide and the single statistical test approaches in response to the applied iron regimes (Comparison 3) provides further evidence that Mo17 is unable to efficiently respond upon low iron availability. Furthermore, the overlap detected between the genotype specific comparisons at both iron regimes might indicate that in addition to the treatment responsive genes, other factors for example such, influencing genotype specific root and shoot development and morphology might also contribute to overall stress tolerance and in consequence might also impact the iron deficiency associated chlorosis response. Whether the differential expression of the identified transcripts is causal for the observed phenotypic differences, or if it is merely a consequence of factors acting up-stream of these genes and modulating their expression needs further functional investigation. Nevertheless, principal component analysis of significant transcripts and their expression patterns allows to clearly separate genotype and treatment samples as well as differentiate a pronounced iron deficiency response for B73, which is not the case for Mo17 (Additional file 1: Figure S1C). This result further substantiates that Mo17 is unable to efficiently respond upon low iron availability.
Differentially expressed transcripts co-localize with QTLs for iron related traits in the IBM population
A first hint, if the identified genes might not only contribute to phenotypic differences between both inbreds as result of genetic background but also to the natural variation of iron efficiency related traits within the IBM population relies in the projection of the corresponding genes onto the genetic map with corresponding QTLs (Benke et al., unpublished). Indeed, 27 genes co-localized within QTL confidence intervals, detected by Benke et al. (Figure 3, Table 2 and Additional file 1: Figure S3). The majority of these genes arose from the genotype specific comparisons (Table 2). However, it is noteworthy that two genes from the comparison of B73 grown at the 10 vs. 300 μM iron regime also mapped to QTL confidence intervals (Table 2). These candidates (GRMZM2G574782 and GRMZM2G423972) encode a putative bifunctional methylribose-1-phosphate dehydratase/enolase phosphatase E1 (DEP1) and a formate dehydrogenase isoform, respectively (Table 2). As both genes are important for methionine salvage pathway, a prerequisite for an efficient phytosiderophore synthesis [6, 31–33], they represent excellent candidates underlying natural variation of iron efficiency within the IBM population (Table 2).
Analysis of iron deficiency associated chlorosis by an integrative approach using transcriptome, functional and pathway information
This hypothesis is further strengthened by a GO-term enrichment and a pathway analysis that highlights the importance methionine, related processes (Figures 4 and 5, Additional file 1: Figure S4) in concordance to comparable studies in other plants [34–39]. Correspondingly, Mo17 displayed higher stress levels even at high iron regime as consequence of an inefficient iron homeostasis (Additional file 1: Figure S4). As amino-acid and carboxylic acid metabolism yield necessary backbones for phytosiderophore synthesis [5, 32], an up-regulation as observed for Mo17 at both iron regimes fortifies the hypothesis of inefficient iron deficiency response for Mo17, independent of physiological iron supply. Even the compensation response of Mo17, increasing amino-acid metabolism and nucleotide as well as methionine salvage pathways,  together with a reduced polyamine synthesis in order to achieve a higher metabolite flux towards phytosiderophore production, as deduced from the transcriptional profile, fails to complement the inefficient iron response (Figure 5, Additional file 1: Figure S4). In contrast, B73 induces nucleotide and methionine salvage pathways only upon limiting iron supply, and does not require modulating polyamine synthesis (Figure 5, Additional file 1: Figure S4). Further evidence for this hypothesis is provided by the up-regulation of metal handling pathways and corresponding transcripts independent of iron concentration in Mo17 (Figure 5, Additional file 1: Figure S4).
Novel candidates and old cues with new twists contribute to the iron responsive transcriptome of B73 and Mo17
A closer analysis of phytosiderophore and strategy II related pathways substantiates the picture of a severely flawed pathway in Mo17 when compared to B73. Whilst the majority of Yang cycle genes  as well as those being involved in phytosiderophore synthesis  are already up-regulated at 300 μM iron in Mo17, all of these are only induced by B73 to similar transcript levels than Mo17 upon limiting iron (Figure 5). A particularly striking fact is that Mo17 shows constitutively high expression levels for these genes at both iron regimes (Figure 5). Intriguingly, NAS1, which was previously thought to be one of three NAS isoforms in maize , was identified as being differentially expressed in the comparison of B73 grown at 10 versus 300 μM iron and represented by two different gene identifiers (Table 3, Additional file 1: Figure S7, S8, S9 and S10). A closer look at the corresponding chromosome region and a BLAST search manifested that two distinct regions harbored all together five NAS1 genes (Additional file 1: Figure S6). The two detected differentially regulated isoforms map to chromosome 9 and are separated by another NAS1 homologue that also shows differences in read coverage between B73 and Mo17. Moreover, the high sequence homology between these isoforms prohibits the correct affiliation of RNA-Seq reads and therefore the detection of truly differentially expressed isoforms. Nevertheless, the deduced read coverage in our study suggests a preferential expression of the isoforms GRMZM2G385200 and GRMZM2G034956 in B73 (Additional file 1: Figure S6). The drop in read coverage within the NAS1 isoform GRMZM2G312481 in B73 in contrast to Mo17 points to an expression that is specific for Mo17 (Additional file 1: Figure S6). However, as the high homology of the corresponding genetic loci hampers the validation of these results by qRT-PCR, other approaches like pyro-sequencing based assays have to be applied in order to fully understand the specific spatio-temporal regulation pattern. In addition to NAS1, also NAAT and a DEP1 homologous transcript showed transcriptional differences within both inbreds upon iron deficiency (Figure 7, Table 3 and Additional file 1: Figures S8 and S10). In contrast to Mo17, which displayed elevated expression levels independent of iron conditions for the corresponding genes, B73 induced the latter only upon iron deficiency to equal levels than Mo17 (Figure 7, Additional file 1: Figures S8 and S10). Correspondingly, we suggest that a transcription factor regulating expression of these and other downstream genes, is either impaired in its regulatory function or its own expression upon the iron deficiency signal.
Interestingly, two bHLH transcription factors, which were significantly induced in B73 upon limited iron showed elevated transcript levels at Mo17 across both iron regimes (Figure 7). These regulators show high homology to IRO2 from rice [23, 40, 41] as well as PYE from Arabidopsis and IRO3 from rice, respectively . The gene, GRMZM2G057413 might encode the maize IRO2 homologue, which is responsible for the induction of iron deficiency related genes, including those involved in nicotianamine synthesis [6, 23]. The high levels of IRO2 in Mo17 even at 300 μM provide an explanation for the elevated expression of genes related to methionine salvage pathway and nicotianamine synthesis [42, 43]. In addition, read coverage within the corresponding gene model exceeded the current one for 20 kb downstream of the putative transcription start (Figure 7, Additional file 1: Figure S7). Surprisingly, read coverage was high in Mo17 in a region far away from the putative transcription start site but at the vicinity of another gene (GRMZM2G057506) with no mapped reads. Interestingly the rice homologue also possesses a bHLH domain (data not shown). Altogether, our data indicate that the gene model for the maize locus GRMZM2G057314 might have to be revised and furthermore that this locus might undergo alternative splicing. In addition, qRT validated higher expression levels for Mo17 even at 300 μM iron but also suggested a further significant induction at 10 μM iron for Mo17 (Figure 7). High IRO2 levels in rice result from the action of the up-stream iron deficiency responsive element-binding factor 1 (IDEF1)[42, 43]. Although, a slight difference in IDEF1 could be detected by qRT (data not shown), the expression pattern within the RNA-Seq data was not significantly different at an FDR < 0.05. Intriguingly, the second bHLH transcription factor showed as closest homologues the rice IRO3 gene and PYE (Popeye) of Arabidopsis. Induction of this gene in B73 upon limiting iron and its expression profile, which is comparable to GRMZM2G057413 in Mo17 (Figure 7) indicates a contribution to efficient iron homeostasis. AtPYE, is known to be involved in maintaining iron homeostasis under low iron conditions and regulating root hair morphology of the strategy I plant Arabidopsis . OsIRO3, which also shows high homology to GRMZM2G350312 has been described as an iron regulated bHLH transcription factor that plays an important role for Fe homeostasis in rice by acting as negative regulator of the Fe deficiency response . The transcription profile of GRMZM2G350312, as observed in this study is identical to the one of IRO3in rice. In this respect, the corresponding maize gene might act analogous to OsIRO3. If both maize transcription factors act independent of each other or are both controlled by higher ranking factors like IDEF1 needs further investigation. Moreover, as bHLH transcription factors often form homo- and/or hetero-dimers [45, 46], a possible interaction of these genes might impact on iron deficiency associated chlorosis of both inbreds. A more essential question that has to be addressed by further experiments is, if solely internal cellular iron levels act as iron deficiency signal and trigger the IDEF1/IRO2 and IRO3 like regulation networks or if other mechanisms are involved. An e-QTL study of the identified iron responsive transcription factors (GRMZM2G057413 and GRMZM2G350312) would provide first answers.
In addition, a putative oligopeptide transporter (GRMZM2G400602) could also be identified that showed an induction in its expression within the RNA-Seq experiment for both genotypes upon limiting iron conditions (Figure 7, Table 3). This regulation pattern could be validated by qRT, although induction upon 10 μM iron regime in replicate B was stronger for Mo17 than for B73 (Figure 7). One might speculate, that this transport protein, which only shows weak homology to the yellow stripe like (YSL) transporter clade  might be involved in the intracellular transport of phytosiderophores, their precursors or related iron complexes. A putative function in phytosiderophore export to the rhizosphere can be excluded, as the maize homologues  of the corresponding gene in rice OsTOM1 differ from this putative oligopetide transporter.
An intriguing finding is the strong expression difference of a putative obtusifoliol-14α demethylase (GRMZM2G096029), which undergoes a down-regulation in B73 upon limiting iron, but displays nearly no expression in Mo17 (Figure 7, Table 3). As this gene is involved in sterol biosynthesis, and as it has been previously described that the relative abundance of Δ5-sterols correlates with aluminum tolerance in rice , a potential consequence of the extremely low transcript expression in Mo17 could be an altered sterol composition of root membranes. As low sterol abundance seems to correlate with higher membrane permeability and an accumulation of metal ions , higher sterol abundance in B73 root tissue might improve its iron efficiency by reducing undesired metal accumulation and toxicity.
In addition, the regulation pattern of the gene GRMZM2G106980 encoding a putative BURP-domain could be due to developmental processes impacted by the stress response as described elsewhere . Moreover, expression of a ClpC1 homologous chaperone gene could also be validated by qRT-PCR (Additional file 1: Figure S8). AtClpC1, has been identified as being responsible for the Arabidopsis mutant phenotype irm1, showing typical Fe-deficiency chlorosis . In this respect, ClpC1 is involved in leaf iron homeostasis, presumably via chloroplast translocation of some nuclear-encoded proteins which function in Fe transport. The homologous gene in maize might fulfill similar functions. The high transcript levels of two cytochrome P450 genes, involved in polyphenol synthesis, in Mo17 at both iron regimes points to an iron deficiency compensation response (Additional file 1: Figures S7 and S10). In this respect, a flawed iron deficiency chlorosis response in Mo17 might lead at both iron conditions to increased production of phenols that, after being excreted to the rhizosphere, solubilize Fe(III) from the soil . Whether this Strategy I related mechanism supports iron assimilation by phytosiderophores  remains theoretical. Another, explanation would be a general stress response of Mo17, which in consequence results in elevated phenol production .
Over 400 significantly regulated transcripts at two iron regimes within both inbreds were identified that besides novel candidate genes included known iron responsive loci. The integration of QTL information and transcriptome data emphasize a contribution of the above mentioned genes to natural variation of the investigated traits. Further analysis of the proposed candidate genes and pathways in a diverse germplasm set will extend our understanding about the impact of the latter to natural trait variation in maize. The presented data is a valuable resource for researcher investigating iron deficiency response in graminaceous and non-graminaceous plants and represents a vantage point for the generation of molecular markers in order to improve iron deficiency chlorosis resistance in maize.
Plant material, hydroponic growth and root tissue sampling
Seeds of the maize genotypes B73 and Mo17 were obtained from the Maize Genetics Cooperation Stock Center (http://maizecoop.cropsci.uiuc.edu/). Maize seeds were sterilized with a 3% NaClO solution for three minutes and then treated with 60°C hot water for another five minutes. Seeds for each genotype were germinated in Petri dishes (Greiner Bio-One GmbH, Frickenhausen, Germany) between two filter paper sheets moistened with saturated CaSO4 solution in the dark at room temperature. After six days of imbibition, germinated seeds were transferred to a continuously aerated nutrient solution with nutrient concentrations as described  and supplied with 100 μM Fe(III)-EDTA for the following seven days. Afterwards, half of the pots representing a genotype group were shifted to either limiting [10 μM Fe(III)-EDTA] or non-limiting [300 μM Fe(III)-EDTA] iron conditions. The nutrient solution was exchanged every third day. Four plants of each genotype were grown in one 5 liter pot until the 28th day in a growth chamber at a relative humidity of 60%, light intensity of 170 μmol m-2⋅s-1 in the leaf canopy, and a day-night temperature regime of 16 h/24°C and 8 h/22°C, respectively. In order to correct for the biological variation, the experiment was carried out two times each with three pots harbouring four plants of a given genotype at the mentioned iron conditions.
Phenotypic evaluation of chlorosis symptoms of the 5th and the 6th leaf, measured as SPAD units (SPAD5, 6), was carried out 25 days after germination for individual plants with a SPAD meter (Konica Minolta SPAD 502, Langenhagen, Germany). All other traits analysed in this study were recorded at harvest (28 days after germination). Root length (RL) and root weight (RW) were measured for all plants in one pot as one sample and root tissue was immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen at harvest for subsequent RNA-Seq analysis. Shoot length (SL) was measured independently for each plant and shoot dry weight (SDW) was evaluated after drying the shoot material for 7 days at 70°C. Dried shoot material of all the plants from one pot was pooled to one sample of each of the two experimental replications. Afterwards, shoot samples were ground and measured for Fe concentration using inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry ICP-MS (Elan 6000, Perkin Elmer Sciex, Rodgau, Germany).
RNA isolation, library construction and RNA-Seq run on Illumina HiSeq2000
After harvest and phenotypic evaluation, frozen root tissue for all plants in one pot was used for RNA isolation. Root tissue samples from three pots each with four plants of a specific genotype at a given iron regime were pooled for each biological replicate (two independent experiments) and ground in a mortar under liquid nitrogen. About 200 mg of tissue from both biological replicates was subjected to total RNA isolation using the Qiagen RNAeasy Plant Mini Kit (QIAGEN, Hilden, Germany). RNA concentration was measured by the QuBit broad range RNA assay kit (Life Technologies GmbH, Darmstadt; Germany) and the QuBit fluorimeter (Life Technologies GmbH, Darmstadt; Germany). Integrity of isolated total RNA and possible DNA contamination was checked on 1.2% agarose gels. DNA contamination was subsequently eliminated, using the Ambion DNA-free TM kit, (Life Technologies GmbH, Darmstadt; Germany). Successful DNAse treatment was monitored on the Agilent Bioanalyser (Agilent Technologies, Böblingen; Germany). Further processing of RNA included an rRNA depletion step using the RiboMinusTM Plant Kit (Life Technologies GmbH, Darmstadt; Germany) and the monitoring of depleted RNA using the Agilent Bioanalyser pico Chip (Agilent Technologies, Böblingen; Germany). RNA-seq libraries were prepared from depleted samples according to the recommendations of the supplier (TruSeq RNA sample preparation v2 guide; Illumina). Libraries were quantified by fluorometry, immobilized and processed onto a flow cell with a cBot (Illumina), followed by sequencing-by-synthesis with TruSeq v3 chemistry on a HiSeq2000 system. Raw sequencing data was processed with Illumina software CASAVA (ver. 1.8.2). Raw data files can be accessed as FASTQ files via the Short Read Archive at NCBI (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra) under the BioProject ID PRJNA187035.
Transcriptomic data analysis
Raw RNA-Seq reads were analysed, using the statistical software R and reads having a Phred score of equal to, or less than 20 in more than 30 percent of the cycles were removed . After creating an indexed reference with Bowtie2 v.2.0.0-beta 6[56, 57] and the current maize sequence (ZmB73_RefGen_v2, http://ftp.maizesequence.org) as well as the reference annotation file (ZmB73_5a, http://ftp.maizesequence.org) , high quality reads were aligned to the reference using TopHat v.2.0.3 with standard settings [17, 59]. The resulting BAM files were sorted and indexed with SAMtools v.1.4 as well as processed to SAM files. The further transcript assembly and calling of differentially expressed transcripts was carried out, using four different procedures. For transcript assembly by cufflinks v.2.0.2, sorted SAM files were used either by providing a annotation file for reference annotation based transcript assembly (RABT) in order to rapidly identify novel transcripts  or without any annotation reference as previously described . The further analysis was performed using cufflinks v.2.0.2 with default settings . In this respect, transcript abundances is calculated in Fragments Per Kilobase of exon per Million fragments mapped (FPKM), which is analagous to Reads Per Kilobase of exon per Million fragments mapped (RPKM) when analysing single-read runs. Subsequent proceeding of Cufflinks output with Cuffcompare, Cuffmerge and Cuffdiff with default settings resulted in determination of differentially expressed transcripts after data normalization in order to correct for differences in both library sizes and gene length. Furthermore, sorted and indexed BAM files were processed with the statistical software R v.2.15.1 and the R package EasyRNASeq by providing an annotation object created by the R packages EasyRNASeq, biomaRt, GenomicRanges and GenomicFeatures. Correspondingly, calling the easyRNASeq() function of the R package EasyRNASeq resulted in tables with raw count data that can be further analysed by the packages DeSeq or edgeR using as output format option within the easyRNASeq() function “DeSeq” or “edgeR”, respectively. The derived count tables for the R packages DeSeq and edgeR were computed per gene models. Identification of differentially expressed transcripts was carried out as previously described [18, 19, 63, 64]. In this respect, normalisation of count data is achieved using the DeSeq functions estimateSizeFactors() and sizeFactors() in order to determine a normalization factor as well as following the trimmed Mean of M-values (TMM) approach using the edgeR function calcNormFactors().
Differentially expressed transcripts were called for specific two-way comparisons for each analysis pipeline (Additional file 2). In this respect, Mo17 transcript expression was compared to B73 at 300 μM and at 10 μM iron supply. In addition, Mo17 as well as B73 transcript expression at 10 μM iron was compared to that present at 300 μM. In order to standardize selection of differentially expressed transcripts the threshold of significance was set to an experiment wide false discovery rate (FDR)  lower than 0.05 for all tests. Only transcripts significant at this experiment wide FDR throughout all four statistical approaches for corresponding two-way comparisons were further analysed.
Genetic map and QTL intervals (Benke et al., unpublished) were used for the projection of the physical positions of differentially expressed and significant genes onto the corresponding map. Information on physical positions, sequences accession numbers and molecular characteristics were retrieved from corresponding web resources [58, 66]. Transcripts showing expression values in all four statistical approaches were projected with their experiment wide median log2FC for specific two-way comparisons onto the physical map for each chromosome.
GO-term enrichment and pathway analysis
Based on version 5b of the filtered gene set of the maize genome, sequences of significantly regulated transcripts within all four two-way comparisons (FDR < 0.05) throughout all four statistical approaches were determined. An unique protein identifier from the UniProt Knowledgebase data set  was identified for each transcript using BLAST software  with an expectation cutoff value of 1e-10. Based on the unique protein identifier, gene ontology (GO) terms were assigned. Singular GO term enrichment analysis  was carried out using the maize transcript sequence file version 5a as reference. To determine significantly enriched GO terms between the significantly regulated genes within the RNA-Seq approach and the reference a hypergeometric test with a level of false discovery rate lower than 0.05 was applied . GO-terms showing a fold enrichment within the last quartile of all values for each category are plotted in Figure 4.
Visualisation of transcript expression differences within specific pathways was carried out, using MapMan v.3.5.1R2. Genes that were identified as differentially expressed within two-way comparisons were used as input together with their median log2FC across all statistical tests. In order to use the mapping file provided by the MapMan homepage (Zm_GENOME_RELEASE_09, http://mapman.gabipd.org), gene identifiers were converted into transcript identifiers by adding the extension “_T01”. Moreover, custom iron homeostasis pathway files (Additional files 3 and 4) were used.
Variant calling and data adjustment
In order to detect polymorphisms between B73 and Mo17, TopHat v.2.0.3 was used to generate BAM files out of all FASTQ files of a given genotype across both iron treatments and the two replications. By using SAMtools v.1.4 BAM files were sorted and indexed. Variant calling was conducted, using the mpileup function with default settings together with the current maize sequence (ZmB73_RefGen_v2) as reference. The SAMtools output was further processed with SAMtools/BCFtools v. v.1.4 into VCF files . VCF files were filtered using R. Only polymorphisms having an average read depth above 10 and being clearly called as homozygous (a single PL value of 0) were kept. The number of polymorphisms (SNPs and INDELs) was computed for arbitrary bins (size = 4 MBps) for each chromosome and plotted along the physical coordinates.
RT-PCR and selection of candidate genes
Candidate gene selection criteria were the following: i) pseudogenes, transposable elements and transcripts giving rise to very small peptides (< 50AA) were omitted from validation by RT-PCR, ii) all genes significantly regulated in the comparison of B73 grown at 300 and 10 μM iron (Comparison 4 – 11 genes), except Nas1 and Fdh, which were represented by multiple isoform as well as the significantly regulated genes of the comparsion of Mo17 grown at 300 and 10 μM iron (Comparison 3 – 3genes) were included in the RT-PCR validation, iii) together with genes significant at the comparisons of both genotypes at 300 and 10 μM iron (Comparison 1 and 2 – 6 genes), respectively and ranging with their experiment wide median P-values within the upper quartile of the corresponding distribution. In addition, 20 known iron responsive genes were also integrated in the validation approach (Additional file 1: Table S4). Total RNA for RT-PCR analysis was extracted from B73 and Mo17 root tissue as described above. After DNAse treatment (Ambion DNA-free, Invitrogen) cDNA synthesis was carried out using Reverse Transcriptase (SuperScript VILO, Life Technologies GmbH, Darmstadt; Germany) and random hexamer primers. Expression analysis by RT-PCR was conducted according to manufacturer’s instructions (DyNAmo ColorFlash SYBR Green qPCR Kit, Biozym Scientific GmbH, Hessisch Oldendorf; Germany) using Actin as an internal control to normalize transcript abundance. Corresponding primers and PCR conditions for candidate gene amplification are given in Additional file 1: Table S4.
De Groote H, Kimenju SC: Consumer preferences for maize products in urban Kenya. Food Nutr Bull. 2012, 33 (2): 99-110.
Bert PF, Bordenave L, Donnart M, Hevin C, Ollat N, Decroocq S: Mapping genetic loci for tolerance to lime-induced iron deficiency chlorosis in grapevine rootstocks (Vitis sp.). Theor Appl Genet. 2012, 126 (2): 451-473.
Abadia J, Vazquez S, Rellan-Alvarez R, El-Jendoubi H, Abadia A, Alvarez-Fernandez A, Lopez-Millan AF: Towards a knowledge-based correction of iron chlorosis. Plant Physiol Biochem. 2011, 49 (5): 471-482. 10.1016/j.plaphy.2011.01.026.
Calace N, Croce G, Petronio BM, Pietroletti M: The increase of iron phytoavailability in soils ammended with paper mill sludge. Ann Chim. 2006, 96 (3–4): 137-145.
Benke A, Stich B: An analysis of selection on candidate genes for regulation, mobilization, uptake, and transport of iron in maize. Genome. 2011, 54 (8): 674-683. 10.1139/g11-031.
Kobayashi T, Nishizawa NK: Iron uptake, translocation, and regulation in higher plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2012, 63: 131-152. 10.1146/annurev-arplant-042811-105522.
Vert G, Grotz N, Dedaldechamp F, Gaymard F, Guerinot ML, Briat JF, Curie C: IRT1, an Arabidopsis transporter essential for iron uptake from the soil and for plant growth. Plant Cell. 2002, 14 (6): 1223-1233. 10.1105/tpc.001388.
Roberts LA, Pierson AJ, Panaviene Z, Walker EL: Yellow stripe1. Expanded roles for the maize iron-phytosiderophore transporter. Plant Physiol. 2004, 135 (1): 112-120. 10.1104/pp.103.037572.
Curie C, Panaviene Z, Loulergue C, Dellaporta SL, Briat JF, Walker EL: Maize yellow stripe1 encodes a membrane protein directly involved in Fe(III) uptake. Nature. 2001, 409 (6818): 346-349. 10.1038/35053080.
Inoue H, Kobayashi T, Nozoye T, Takahashi M, Kakei Y, Suzuki K, Nakazono M, Nakanishi H, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: Rice OsYSL15 is an iron-regulated iron(III)-deoxymugineic acid transporter expressed in the roots and is essential for iron uptake in early growth of the seedlings. J Biol Chem. 2009, 284 (6): 3470-3479.
Kobayashi T, Nakanishi H, Nishizawa NK: Recent insights into iron homeostasis and their application in graminaceous crops. Proc Jpn Acad Ser B Phys Biol Sci. 2010, 86 (9): 900-913. 10.2183/pjab.86.900.
Kobayashi T, Ogo Y, Aung MS, Nozoye T, Itai RN, Nakanishi H, Yamakawa T, Nishizawa NK: The spatial expression and regulation of transcription factors IDEF1 and IDEF2. Ann Bot. 2010, 105 (7): 1109-1117. 10.1093/aob/mcq002.
Xiao H, Yin L, Xu X, Li T, Han Z: The iron-regulated transporter, MbNRAMP1, isolated from Malus baccata is involved in Fe Mn and Cd trafficking. Ann Bot. 2008, 102 (6): 881-889. 10.1093/aob/mcn178.
Xiong H, Kobayashi T, Kakei Y, Senoura T, Nakazono M, Takahashi H, Nakanishi H, Shen H, Duan P, Guo X, et al: AhNRAMP1 iron transporter is involved in iron acquisition in peanut. J Exp Bot. 2012, 63 (12): 4437-4446. 10.1093/jxb/ers117.
Mercer TR, Gerhardt DJ, Dinger ME, Crawford J, Trapnell C, Jeddeloh JA, Mattick JS, Rinn JL: Targeted RNA sequencing reveals the deep complexity of the human transcriptome. Nat Biotechnol. 2012, 30 (1): 99-104.
Trapnell C, Hendrickson DG, Sauvageau M, Goff L, Rinn JL, Pachter L: Differential analysis of gene regulation at transcript resolution with RNA-seq. Nat Biotechnol. 2012, 31: 46-53. 10.1038/nbt.2450.
Trapnell C, Roberts A, Goff L, Pertea G, Kim D, Kelley DR, Pimentel H, Salzberg SL, Rinn JL, Pachter L: Differential gene and transcript expression analysis of RNA-seq experiments with TopHat and Cufflinks. Nat Protoc. 2012, 7 (3): 562-578. 10.1038/nprot.2012.016.
Anders S, Huber W: Differential expression analysis for sequence count data. Genome Biol. 2010, 11 (10): R106. 10.1186/gb-2010-11-10-r106.
Robinson MD, McCarthy DJ, Smyth GK: edgeR: a Bioconductor package for differential expression analysis of digital gene expression data. Bioinformatics. 2010, 26 (1): 139-140. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btp616.
Springer NM, Ying K, Fu Y, Ji T, Yeh CT, Jia Y, Wu W, Richmond T, Kitzman J, Rosenbaum H, et al: Maize inbreds exhibit high levels of copy number variation (CNV) and presence/absence variation (PAV) in genome content. PLoS Genet. 2009, 5 (11): e1000734. 10.1371/journal.pgen.1000734.
Mizuno D, Higuchi K, Sakamoto T, Nakanishi H, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: Three nicotianamine synthase genes isolated from maize are differentially regulated by iron nutritional status. Plant Physiol. 2003, 132 (4): 1989-1997. 10.1104/pp.102.019869.
Long TA, Tsukagoshi H, Busch W, Lahner B, Salt DE, Benfey PN: The bHLH transcription factor POPEYE regulates response to iron deficiency in Arabidopsis roots. Plant Cell. 2010, 22 (7): 2219-2236. 10.1105/tpc.110.074096.
Ogo Y, Itai RN, Nakanishi H, Inoue H, Kobayashi T, Suzuki M, Takahashi M, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: Isolation and characterization of IRO2, a novel iron-regulated bHLH transcription factor in graminaceous plants. J Exp Bot. 2006, 57 (11): 2867-2878. 10.1093/jxb/erl054.
Xu H, Li Y, Yan Y, Wang K, Gao Y, Hu Y: Genome-scale identification of soybean BURP domain-containing genes and their expression under stress treatments. BMC Plant Biol. 2010, 10: 197. 10.1186/1471-2229-10-197.
Chia JM, Song C, Bradbury PJ, Costich D, de Leon N, Doebley J, Elshire RJ, Gaut B, Geller L, Glaubitz JC, et al: Maize HapMap2 identifies extant variation from a genome in flux. Nat Genet. 2012, 44 (7): 803-807. 10.1038/ng.2313.
Stupar RM, Springer NM: Cis-transcriptional variation in maize inbred lines B73 and Mo17 leads to additive expression patterns in the F1 hybrid. Genetics. 2006, 173 (4): 2199-2210. 10.1534/genetics.106.060699.
Gore MA, Chia JM, Elshire RJ, Sun Q, Ersoz ES, Hurwitz BL, Peiffer JA, McMullen MD, Grills GS, Ross-Ibarra J, et al: A first-generation haplotype map of maize. Science. 2009, 326 (5956): 1115-1117. 10.1126/science.1177837.
Swanson-Wagner R, Briskine R, Schaefer R, Hufford MB, Ross-Ibarra J, Myers CL, Tiffin P, Springer NM: Reshaping of the maize transcriptome by domestication. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012, 109 (29): 11878-11883. 10.1073/pnas.1201961109.
van Heerwaarden J, Hufford MB, Ross-Ibarra J: Historical genomics of North American maize. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012, 109 (31): 12420-12425. 10.1073/pnas.1209275109.
Dillies MA, Rau A, Aubert J, Hennequet-Antier C, Jeanmougin M, Servant N, Keime C, Marot G, Castel D, Estelle J, et al: A comprehensive evaluation of normalization methods for Illumina high-throughput RNA sequencing data analysis. Brief Bioinform. 2012, 17 (6): 671-683.
Kobayashi T, Suzuki M, Inoue H, Itai RN, Takahashi M, Nakanishi H, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: Expression of iron-acquisition-related genes in iron-deficient rice is co-ordinately induced by partially conserved iron-deficiency-responsive elements. J Exp Bot. 2005, 56 (415): 1305-1316. 10.1093/jxb/eri131.
Pommerrenig B, Feussner K, Zierer W, Rabinovych V, Klebl F, Feussner I, Sauer N: Phloem-specific expression of Yang cycle genes and identification of novel Yang cycle enzymes in Plantago and Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2011, 23 (5): 1904-1919. 10.1105/tpc.110.079657.
Takahashi H, Kopriva S, Giordano M, Saito K, Hell R: Sulfur assimilation in photosynthetic organisms: molecular functions and regulations of transporters and assimilatory enzymes. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2011, 62: 157-184. 10.1146/annurev-arplant-042110-103921.
Astolfi S, Zuchi S, Hubberten HM, Pinton R, Hoefgen R: Supply of sulphur to S-deficient young barley seedlings restores their capability to cope with iron shortage. J Exp Bot. 2010, 61 (3): 799-806. 10.1093/jxb/erp346.
Buckhout TJ, Yang TJ, Schmidt W: Early iron-deficiency-induced transcriptional changes in Arabidopsis roots as revealed by microarray analyses. BMC Genomics. 2009, 10: 147. 10.1186/1471-2164-10-147.
Nagasaka S, Takahashi M, Nakanishi-Itai R, Bashir K, Nakanishi H, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: Time course analysis of gene expression over 24 hours in Fe-deficient barley roots. Plant Mol Biol. 2009, 69 (5): 621-631. 10.1007/s11103-008-9443-0.
O'Rourke JA, Charlson DV, Gonzalez DO, Vodkin LO, Graham MA, Cianzio SR, Grusak MA, Shoemaker RC: Microarray analysis of iron deficiency chlorosis in near-isogenic soybean lines. BMC Genomics. 2007, 8: 476. 10.1186/1471-2164-8-476.
Zamboni A, Zanin L, Tomasi N, Pezzotti M, Pinton R, Varanini Z, Cesco S: Genome-wide microarray analysis of tomato roots showed defined responses to iron deficiency. BMC Genomics. 2012, 13: 101. 10.1186/1471-2164-13-101.
Zheng L, Huang F, Narsai R, Wu J, Giraud E, He F, Cheng L, Wang F, Wu P, Whelan J, et al: Physiological and transcriptome analysis of iron and phosphorus interaction in rice seedlings. Plant Physiol. 2009, 151 (1): 262-274. 10.1104/pp.109.141051.
Ogo Y, Itai RN, Kobayashi T, Aung MS, Nakanishi H, Nishizawa NK: OsIRO2 is responsible for iron utilization in rice and improves growth and yield in calcareous soil. Plant Mol Biol. 2011, 75 (6): 593-605. 10.1007/s11103-011-9752-6.
Ogo Y, Itai RN, Nakanishi H, Kobayashi T, Takahashi M, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: The rice bHLH protein OsIRO2 is an essential regulator of the genes involved in Fe uptake under Fe-deficient conditions. Plant J. 2007, 51 (3): 366-377. 10.1111/j.1365-313X.2007.03149.x.
Kobayashi T, Itai RN, Ogo Y, Kakei Y, Nakanishi H, Takahashi M, Nishizawa NK: The rice transcription factor IDEF1 is essential for the early response to iron deficiency, and induces vegetative expression of late embryogenesis abundant genes. Plant J. 2009, 60 (6): 948-961. 10.1111/j.1365-313X.2009.04015.x.
Kobayashi T, Ogo Y, Itai RN, Nakanishi H, Takahashi M, Mori S, Nishizawa NK: The transcription factor IDEF1 regulates the response to and tolerance of iron deficiency in plants. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007, 104 (48): 19150-19155. 10.1073/pnas.0707010104.
Zheng L, Ying Y, Wang L, Wang F, Whelan J, Shou H: Identification of a novel iron regulated basic helix-loop-helix protein involved in Fe homeostasis in Oryza sativa. BMC Plant Biol. 2010, 10: 166. 10.1186/1471-2229-10-166.
Ma PC, Rould MA, Weintraub H, Pabo CO: Crystal structure of MyoD bHLH domain-DNA complex: perspectives on DNA recognition and implications for transcriptional activation. Cell. 1994, 77 (3): 451-459. 10.1016/0092-8674(94)90159-7.
Shimizu T, Toumoto A, Ihara K, Shimizu M, Kyogoku Y, Ogawa N, Oshima Y, Hakoshima T: Crystal structure of PHO4 bHLH domain-DNA complex: flanking base recognition. Embo J. 1997, 16 (15): 4689-4697. 10.1093/emboj/16.15.4689.
Kobayashi T, Itai RN, Aung MS, Senoura T, Nakanishi H, Nishizawa NK: The rice transcription factor IDEF1 directly binds to iron and other divalent metals for sensing cellular iron status. Plant J. 2012, 69 (1): 81-91. 10.1111/j.1365-313X.2011.04772.x.
Curie C, Cassin G, Couch D, Divol F, Higuchi K, Le Jean M, Misson J, Schikora A, Czernic P, Mari S: Metal movement within the plant: contribution of nicotianamine and yellow stripe 1-like transporters. Ann Bot. 2009, 103 (1): 1-11.
Nozoye T, Nakanishi H, Nishizawa NK: Characterizing the Crucial Components of Iron Homeostasis in the Maize Mutants ys1 and ys3. PLoS One. 2013, 8 (5): e62567. 10.1371/journal.pone.0062567.
Nozoye T, Nagasaka S, Kobayashi T, Takahashi M, Sato Y, Uozumi N, Nakanishi H, Nishizawa NK: Phytosiderophore efflux transporters are crucial for iron acquisition in graminaceous plants. J Biol Chem. 2011, 286 (7): 5446-5454. 10.1074/jbc.M110.180026.
Khan MS, Tawaraya K, Sekimoto H, Koyama H, Kobayashi Y, Murayama T, Chuba M, Kambayashi M, Shiono Y, Uemura M, et al: Relative abundance of Delta(5)-sterols in plasma membrane lipids of root-tip cells correlates with aluminum tolerance of rice. Physiol Plant. 2009, 135 (1): 73-83. 10.1111/j.1399-3054.2008.01175.x.
Wu H, Ji Y, Du J, Kong D, Liang H, Ling HQ: ClpC1, an ATP-dependent Clp protease in plastids, is involved in iron homeostasis in Arabidopsis leaves. Ann Bot. 2010, 105 (5): 823-833. 10.1093/aob/mcq051.
Abdullahil Baque M, Lee EJ, Paek KY: Medium salt strength induced changes in growth, physiology and secondary metabolite content in adventitious roots of Morinda citrifolia: the role of antioxidant enzymes and phenylalanine ammonia lyase. Plant Cell Rep. 2010, 29 (7): 685-694. 10.1007/s00299-010-0854-4.
von Wiren N, Marschner H, Romheld V: Roots of iron-efficient maize also absorb phytosiderophore-chelated zinc. Plant Physiol. 1996, 111 (4): 1119-1125.
Garg R, Patel RK, Tyagi AK, Jain M: De novo assembly of chickpea transcriptome using short reads for gene discovery and marker identification. DNA Res. 2011, 18 (1): 53-63. 10.1093/dnares/dsq028.
Langmead B: Aligning short sequencing reads with Bowtie. Curr Protoc Bioinform. 2010, 32: 11.7.1-11.7.14.
Langmead B, Trapnell C, Pop M, Salzberg SL: Ultrafast and memory-efficient alignment of short DNA sequences to the human genome. Genome Biol. 2009, 10 (3): R25. 10.1186/gb-2009-10-3-r25.
Schnable PS, Ware D, Fulton RS, Stein JC, Wei F, Pasternak S, Liang C, Zhang J, Fulton L, Graves TA, et al: The B73 maize genome: complexity, diversity, and dynamics. Science. 2009, 326 (5956): 1112-1115. 10.1126/science.1178534.
Trapnell C, Pachter L, Salzberg SL: TopHat: discovering splice junctions with RNA-Seq. Bioinformatics. 2009, 25 (9): 1105-1111. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btp120.
Li H, Handsaker B, Wysoker A, Fennell T, Ruan J, Homer N, Marth G, Abecasis G, Durbin R: The sequence alignment/Map format and SAMtools. Bioinformatics. 2009, 25 (16): 2078-2079. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btp352.
Roberts A, Pimentel H, Trapnell C, Pachter L: Identification of novel transcripts in annotated genomes using RNA-Seq. Bioinformatics. 2011, 27 (17): 2325-2329. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btr355.
R Development Core Team: R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing; 2008, 3-900051-07-0
Delhomme N, Padioleau I, Furlong EE, Steinmetz LM: easyRNASeq: a bioconductor package for processing RNA-Seq data. Bioinformatics. 2012, 28 (19): 2532-2533. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bts477.
Kvam VM, Liu P, Si Y: A comparison of statistical methods for detecting differentially expressed genes from RNA-seq data. Am J Bot. 2012, 99 (2): 248-256. 10.3732/ajb.1100340.
Benjamini Y, Hochberg Y: Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. J R Stat Soc Ser B Methodol. 1995, 57 (1): 289-300.
Lawrence CJ, Harper LC, Schaeffer ML, Sen TZ, Seigfried TE, Campbell DA: MaizeGDB: the maize model organism database for basic, translational, and applied research. Int J Plant Genom. 2008, 2008: 496957.
Jain E, Bairoch A, Duvaud S, Phan I, Redaschi N, Suzek BE, Martin MJ, McGarvey P, Gasteiger E: Infrastructure for the life sciences: design and implementation of the UniProt website. BMC Bioinforma. 2009, 10: 136. 10.1186/1471-2105-10-136.
Altschul SF, Wootton JC, Gertz EM, Agarwala R, Morgulis A, Schaffer AA, Yu YK: Protein database searches using compositionally adjusted substitution matrices. Febs J. 2005, 272 (20): 5101-5109. 10.1111/j.1742-4658.2005.04945.x.
Du Z, Zhou X, Ling Y, Zhang Z, Su Z: agriGO: a GO analysis toolkit for the agricultural community. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010, 38: W64-70. 10.1093/nar/gkq310. (Web Server issue)
Thiemann A, Fu J, Schrag TA, Melchinger AE, Frisch M, Scholten S: Correlation between parental transcriptome and field data for the characterization of heterosis in Zea mays L. Theor Appl Genet. 2010, 120 (2): 401-413. 10.1007/s00122-009-1189-9.
Usadel B, Poree F, Nagel A, Lohse M, Czedik-Eysenberg A, Stitt M: A guide to using MapMan to visualize and compare Omics data in plants: a case study in the crop species, Maize. Plant Cell Environ. 2009, 32 (9): 1211-1229. 10.1111/j.1365-3040.2009.01978.x.
Danecek P, Auton A, Abecasis G, Albers CA, Banks E, DePristo MA, Handsaker RE, Lunter G, Marth GT, Sherry ST, et al: The variant call format and VCFtools. Bioinformatics. 2011, 27 (15): 2156-2158. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btr330.
We would like to thank Maarten Koornneef for valuable discussion and critical reading of the manuscript. We also would like to thank the MGCSC for providing seeds of the IBM population. Moreover, we thank Nicole Kliche-Kamphaus, Andrea Lossow, and Nele Kaul for excellent technical support. In addition, we also would like to thank Astrid Draffehn for critical reading of the manuscript and helpful suggestions. Part of the work was carried out in the Department for Genetics and Plant Breeding headed by Maarten Koornneef. Funding was granted by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and the Max Planck Society.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
CU, AB and JM carried out the hydroponic growth of maize genotypes, tissue sampling, phenotypic evaluation and all molecular laboratory procedures. CU designed and evaluated the RNA-Seq experiment and conducted raw-data analysis. CU and AB carried out further computational analysis of transcriptome data. CU and BS conceived of the study and drafted the manuscript. BH and RR conceived of the study and provided “next-generation sequencing” infrastructure. BH carried out the Illumina HiSeq run. All authors read and approved the manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 3: MapMan Pathway file. JPG file for siderophore and Fe homeostasis related transcripts adopted from Benke et al. without transcript bins. (JPEG 144 KB)
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Urbany, C., Benke, A., Marsian, J. et al. Ups and downs of a transcriptional landscape shape iron deficiency associated chlorosis of the maize inbreds B73 and Mo17. BMC Plant Biol 13, 213 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2229-13-213
- Iron deficiency
- IBM population
- Natural variation
- Zea mays