Skip to main content

Table 1 Morphological comparison between fossil species of Mesocyparis

From: Fossil evidence reveals how plants responded to cooling during the Cretaceous-Paleogene transition

Taxa

M. sinica

M. borealis

M. umbonata

M. beringiana

M. rosanovii

Seed Cone

 Length (mm)

4.4–5.2

3.0–5.0

2.8–5.0

2.0–4.0

3.5–5.0

 Width (mm)

4.0–5.1

3.0–5.0

1.9–4.0

2.0–4.0

3.0–4.0

 Arrangement

opposite

opposite

decussate*

decussate*

most decussate, a few opposite*

Cone Scale

 shape

obovate to ovate

obovate

peltate*

ovate

peltate*

 Length (mm)

3.7–4.3

3.0–5.0

2.3–4.0

no data

no data

 Width (mm)

2.8–3.1

3.0

1.8–3.9

no data

no data

 number

4

4

4

4

4

 size of the two pairs

approximately equal in size

approximately equal in size

upper pair larger than lower*

upper pair larger than lower*

approximately equal in size

 position of umbo on cone scale

near the apex

near the apex

in center*

near the apex

near the apex

 Shape of umbo’ s tip

acuminate

acute*

acute*

acute*

acute*

 Shape of umbo

erect

reflexed*

erect

erect

erect

Branch

 Arrangement

opposite, forming flat frond-like sprays

opposite, forming flat frond-like sprays

more than 1/4 alternate, others opposite*

opposite, forming flat frond-like sprays

most opposite, a few alternate*

Leaf

 Facia and lateral leaves of fertile shoots

dimorphic

dimorphic

monomorphic*

dimorphic

monomorphic*

Shootlet

 Length of facial leaves (mm)

1.1–2.1

2.0–3.0

0.8–2.0

0.5–0.6

1.5

 Width of facial leaves (mm)

0.8–1.6

1.2–2.0

0.6–1.2

no data

1.0

 Length of lateral leaves (mm)

0.9–2.4

2.0–3.0

0.5–2.0

no data

no data

 Width of lateral leaves (mm)

0.4–0.8

0.5–1.0

0.1–0.4

no data

no data

 facial leaves overlap

Present

Present

Present

Absent*

Present

 lateral leaves overlap

Present

Present

Present

Absent*

Present

Shoot

 Length of facial leaves (mm)

1.8–3.8

3.5–6.0

1.4–4.0

2.0–3.0

1.5–3.0

 Width of facial leaves (mm)

0.4–0.6

0.5–1.0

0.5–0.9

1.5–2.0

0.8–2.0

 Length of lateral leaves (mm)

1.7–2.7

3.5–5.0

1.5–3.8

no data

1.5–3.0

 Width of lateral leaves (mm)

0.4–0.5

0.5–1.0

0.2–0.6

no data

0.4–0.8

 facial leaves overlapping

Present

no data

Absent*

no data

Absent*

 facial leaves appressed

Present

Present

Present

no data

Present

 lateral leaves overlap

Absent

Absent

Absent

no data

Absent

 apices of lateral leaves free

Present

Present

Present

no data

Present

 Location

Heilongjiang, China

Saskatchewan, Canada

Alberta, Canada

Koryak, Russia

Amur Region, Russia

 Age

Early Paleocene

Paleocene

Masstrichtian

Masstrichtian

Early Paleocene

 Reference

this paper

[18]

[22]

[19, 20, 22]

[21]

  1. “*” indicating character differences between Mesocyparis sinica and other four Mesocyparis species