Application of genome-wide insertion/deletion markers on genetic structure analysis and identity signature of Malus accessions

Background Apple (Malus ssp.), one of the most important temperate fruit crops, has a long cultivation history and is economically important. To identify the genetic relationships among the apple germplasm accessions, whole-genome structural variants identified between M. domestica cultivars ‘Jonathan’ and ‘Golden Delicious’ were used. Results A total of 25,924 insertions and deletions (InDels) were obtained, from which 102 InDel markers were developed. Using the InDel markers, we found that 942 (75.3%) of the 1251 Malus accessions from 35 species exhibited a unique identity signature due to their distinct genotype combinations. The 102 InDel markers could distinguish 16.7–71.4% of the 331 bud sports derived from ‘Fuji’, ‘Red Delicious’, ‘Gala’, ‘Golden Delicious’, and other cultivars. Five distinct genetic patterns were found in 1002 diploid accessions based on 78 bi-allele InDel markers. Genetic structure analysis indicated that M. domestica showed higher genetic diversity than the other species. Malus underwent a relatively high level of wild-to-crop or crop-to-wild gene flow. M. sieversii was closely related to both M. domestica and cultivated Chinese cultivars. Conclusions The identity signatures of Malus accessions can be used to determine distinctness, uniformity, and stability. The results of this study may also provide better insight into the genetic relationships among Malus species. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12870-020-02744-2.


Background
Apple (Malus ssp.), one of the most commonly cultivated fruit crops, supports many local economies in temperate zones. Malus is extremely rich in diversity, with 25 to 78 species in the genus depending on the taxonomic classifications [51,56]. High levels of interspecific hybridization occur naturally, which generates genetic admixtures, contributing to the diversity within the genus [6,7,12]. In addition to the natural diversification of the genus, anthropogenic activities, including selection and cross breeding, have led to approximately 10,000 cultivars worldwide [8,21,65]. Identification of the distinctness of the germplasm would be beneficial to the successful conservation and efficient utilization of genetic resources.
The genetic variability and allelic diversity in these accessions are usually examined to reveal their distinctness. Identification of population structure and kinship within germplasm collections is a fundamental prerequisite for identifying robust marker-trait associations [68]. There are also possibly duplicates, synonyms, homonyms, or materials with missing names that must be carefully examined among the living collections [40]. For example, a previous study identified 330 apple cultivars or abandoned trees that could be either grafted clones or 'own rooted seedlings' using nine SSR markers [24]. In addition, the test for distinctness, uniformity, and stability (DUST) is a statutory requirement to release a new cultivar (International Union for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants (UPOV) Convention Articles 5-9, 991) [64]. Limited by the fact that traditional field tests are time-consuming, laborious, and greatly influenced by the environment, DNA markers are used in DUST in many species [25,58]. Therefore, it is also necessary to develop an efficient marker-assisted DUST protocol in Malus plants.
Owing to the co-dominant inheritance and because they are often multi-allelic, simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers have been widely used in apples to evaluate genetic diversity, population structure, and to analyze parentage [16,23,30,32,40,43,65]. However, the disadvantages of SSRs are frequently reported. The instability of SSRs increased dramatically with plant age [22]. Certain chemicals or radiation may cause DNA double-strand breaks, and the repair of these breaks usually results in small insertions or deletions (InDels) at the break site. These InDels presumably contribute to the instability of SSRs [22]. Errors can also be found in the documented parentage of some accessions by comparing the SSR profiles to show parent-offspring similarity [16,46].
Single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers are commonly used in large-scale, high-throughput automated detection of genetic variation because of their large number and wide distribution in the genome [44,67]. A previous study used an 8 K apple SNP array [5] to identify cryptic relationships between accessions, analyze population structure, and calculate the linkage disequilibrium in apple [68]. Similarly, 3704 confident SNPs were used to analyze a core collection of cider and dessert French apple cultivars [34].
In addition to SSR and SNP markers, InDels have been recognized as an ideal source for marker development due to their high-density, co-dominance, robust stability, and genotyping efficiency [28,74]. InDel markers have been used to identify the specificity of germplasm resources and provide information for breeding in chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) [28], cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) [74], pepper (Capsicum spp. L.) [26], Carapa guianensis [63], mung bean (Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek) [35], and cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) [36]. In addition, InDel markers have been successfully used to distinguish somatic variations in apple [33], although InDel markers have not been as widely used in apple as SSRs and SNPs.
The objectives of the current study were to develop a set of stable co-dominant InDel markers and to identify Malus accessions. Genome-wide InDels were robustly used for analysis of distinctness, genetic structure, genetic composition, and the parentage of 1251 Malus accessions. The results provided insight into Malus germplasm resources and may facilitate the future utilization of germplasm in apple breeding.

Results
Genome-wide structural variant (SV) calling and selection of InDel markers The next generation resequencing data from the two apple founder cultivars, 'Jonathan' and 'Golden Delicious', resulted in an average read depth of 43.44 and have been deposited in the NCBI Sequence Read Archive (SRA) with the accession number PRJNA392908 [60]. A total of 66,841 genome-wide SVs between 'Jonathan' and 'Golden Delicious' were obtained using the apple genome v1.0 as reference [69], including 16,130 deletions (DEL), 9794 insertions (INS), 430 inversions (INV), 1132 intra-chromosomal translocations (ITX), and 39,355 inter-chromosomal translocations (CTX) (Fig. 1a-c). Our results showed that InDels were more well-distributed on chromosomes than the other types of SVs (Fig. 1c). The length of the majority of DEL (78.15%) and INS (99.53%) ranged from 50 bp to 400 bp (Fig. 1b), indicating that InDels are more representative for genome-wide marker development because of their large number and frequent distribution throughout the genome.
Of the 170 InDels chosen throughout the genome (10 per chromosome), 102 were validated for further analyses (example of validated Indel in Fig. 2a and b, list of validated InDels in Table S1). These InDels were combined into nine fluorescence multiplex PCR groups; each group contained three to 24 InDel markers (Table S2).

Genotyping of the selected InDel markers and generation of identity signatures of accessions
Of the 1251 Malus accessions included in this study, 942 exhibited unique genotype combinations (Table S3). Three hundred and nine accessions shared genotype combinations with at least one of the other accessions, which comprised of 76 distinct patterns (Tables S3 and  S4). Sixty-one accessions were found to be synonyms (including 2 with known alternative names), 78 were homonyms, and 8 were replicated collections (Table S5). The genotypes of two tetraploids, 'Zumi Crab 4x' (B-21) and 'Gala 4x' (XC-4), were the same as their diploid progenitors, 'Zumi Crab' (B-30) and 'Ruihong' (QD-25), respectively (Table S4). There were 199 accessions that were mutants of nine known cultivars (Table S4) and 22 accessions had registration errors or incorrect names (Table S5). Excluding synonyms and accessions with errors or incorrect names, 1018 accessions were identified as unique by the 102 InDel markers (Table S3). The InDel identity signature was then generated for each of

Identification of somatic mutants
In this study, 331 of the included 981 Malus domestica Borkh. accessions were bud sports derived from commercially used cultivars. These mutants included 160 bud sports of 'Fuji', 60 bud sports of 'Red Delicious', 60 bud sports of 'Gala', and 40 bud sports derived from each of the following cultivars: 'Golden Delicious', 'Tsugaru', 'Jonathan', and 'Ralls Janet' (Fig. 3).
Fifty-three (33.1%) of the 160 'Fuji' mutants were distinguished from the other 'Fuji' bud sports. The remaining 107 'Fuji' bud sports were classified into 11 subgroups, each composed of two to 75 accessions ( Fig. 3; Tables S3  and S4). Similarly, among the 'Red Delicious' bud sports, the genotypes of 24 (40.0%) of the 60 accessions were distinct from the other 'Red Delicious' bud sports, whereas the other 36 bud sports shared three genotype combinations ( Fig. 3; Tables S3 and S4). Twenty-six (43.3%) of the 60 'Gala' bud sports were distinct using these InDel markers; 34 bud sports showed six genotype combinations ( Fig. 3; Tables S3 and S4). Regarding the bud sports of 'Golden Delicious', 'Tsugaru', 'Jonathan', and 'Ralls Janet', 10 of the 14 (71.4%), six of the 10 (60.0%), three of 10 (30.0%), and one of the six (16.7%) were uniquely distinguished, respectively ( Fig. 3; Tables S3 and S4).  The proportions of bud sports from cultivated apple cultivars that were distinguishable using the 102 insertion/deletion markers Furthermore, we compared the marker genotypes of 24 bud sports derived from 'Fuji', 'Gala', and 'Red Delicious' with the corresponding wildtype cultivars. The wildtype cultivar (e.g. 'Starking') of a certain bud sport (e.g. 'Starkrimson') refers to the cultivar from which the bud sport has been selected. A wildtype cultivar (e.g. 'Starking') can sometimes also be a bud sport of an older cultivar (e.g. 'Red Delicious'). The genotypes of the 102 InDel markers of five bud sports were identical to the corresponding wildtype cultivars (Table S6). Polymorphisms in at least one marker were detected in 19 bud sports compared with the corresponding wildtype cultivars.

Genetic composition of the InDel markers
Five genotype distribution patterns were detected among the 78 biallelic InDel markers using the unique 1002 diploid accessions ( Fig. 4; Table S7). Pattern I (38 markers) was characterized by the relatively low frequency (7.0%) of homozygous INS in M. domestica compared with the extremely high frequency (71.9%) of homozygous DEL genotypes. In other species than M. domestica, much lower frequency (2.0%) of homozygous INS genotypes were detected and the frequency of genotypes with heterozygous DEL:INS was also relatively low ( Fig. 4; Table S7). Four markers showed pattern II genotype distribution, where the homozygous DEL genotypes were detected in low frequencies in M. domestica and were rare or completely absent in other species ( Fig. 4; Table S7). Pattern III (11 markers) exhibited no obvious distortion in marker genotype frequency distribution but few marker/species combinations complied with Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium ( Fig. 4; Table S7). Pattern IV (9 markers) was characterized by extremely high frequency (80.0%) of heterozygous DEL:INS genotype in every species, except for five markers in M. baccata, of which the frequency of homozygous DEL genotypes was higher ( Fig. 4; Table S7). Pattern V (16 markers) showed the same pattern as pattern III ( Fig. 4; Table S7).

Parentage analysis
The parentage analysis allowed for the identification of the parent-offspring relationships among the accessions. The parentage of 66 cultivars was confirmed (Table S8), and the documented parentage of six accessions was found to be incorrect ( Table 1). The cultivar '53-205', which was believed to be a hybrid from 'Jonathan' × ' Golden Delicious', was found to be a first-generation offspring of 'Jonathan' × 'Miyazaki Spur Fuji'. Two supposed full-siblings, '33-018' and '33-101', hybrids with the parents 'Zisai Pearl' × 'Golden Delicious', were identified to be half-siblings instead; the male parents were 'Miyazaki Spur Fuji' and unknown, respectively. Similarly, the parentage of 'H5-101', '50-32', and '62-45' was corrected ( Table 1). The unknown parents of seven cultivars were hypothesized based on the parent-offspring relationships. For example, 'Harlikar' was selected in Japan from an open pollinated progeny of 'Golden Delicious'. Herein, we propose that the paternal parent was 'Oregon Spur II' or a related somatic mutant of 'Red Delicious' (Table 1).

Genetic structure analysis
A genetic structure analysis was generated based on 173 accessions of seven Malus species (Table S9). All seven Malus species showed relatively low inbreeding coefficients, indicating a low level of population structure within these species (Table 2). Both the highest expected (He) and the highest observed heterozygosity (Ho) were obtained in M. domestica. Conversely, the lowest level of genetic diversity was detected in M. baccata, as shown by the lowest He and Ho (Table 2). Similarly, the highest and the lowest average number of effective alleles were observed in M. domestica and M. baccata, respectively ( Table 2).
To estimate the genetic differentiation between Malus species, pairwise differentiation (Fst) values were calculated and all Fst values were highly significant (P < 0.001) ( Table 3). The highest level of genetic differentiation was found between M. baccata and all of the other species (Fst = 0.061-0.129). The differentiation between M. domestica and the six other species (Fst = 0.033-0.129) was higher compared to the other five species (Fst = 0.02-0.037) ( Table 3).
Genetic discrimination between the seven species was confirmed through a multivariate Principal Component Analysis (PCA) (Fig. 5a). In the bi-dimensional plot, we found that the two species M. domestica and M. baccata were completely separate (Fig. 5a). M. asiatica was divided into two groups; one was distributed in the lower right corner adjacent to M. sieversii, while the other was admixed with M. domestica. Most accessions of M. pumila admixed with M. sieversii, whereas M. robusta and M. prunifolia were scattered with other species (Fig. 5a).
Relationships among the accessions of the seven different Malus species were also depicted using a phylogenetic analysis (Fig. 5b). Our results showed that most accessions of M. sieversii, M. pumila, and M. baccata formed separate clades. Twelve of the 20 M. asiatica accessions were typically found to be closely related to M. sieversii. M. robusta and M. prunifolia were largely clustered in the same clade (Fig. 5b). M. baccata was found to be basal to the other six species, whereas M. domestica was at the distal end of the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 5b) (Fig. 5b).
Finally, relationships among the Malus species were explored using ADMIXTURE cross-validation, which indicated that K = 6 was a sensible modeling choice; the other inflection points were K = 4 and K = 7 ( Figure S1).

Discussion
Benefited from the high quality assemblies of the apple genome [13,69,75], large scale of SNP and InDel markers can be easily obtained [48]. In this study, we detected a total of 25,924 InDels between the two cultivars, 'Jonathan' and 'Golden Delicious'. These InDels provided a large reservoir for high performance PCR-based DNA markers for the Malus genus [41,66]. One hundred and two of these InDel markers were applied in this study to the following analyses in Malus accessions.

The application of genome-wide InDel markers on the genetic structure analysis of Malus accessions
Seventy-eight bi-allele InDel markers were used in investigating the relationship between the seven Malus species. Lower He and Ho values, as well as lower average number of effective alleles were detected in the other six species than in M. domestica with the lowest values detected in M. baccata. Although these lower levels of He, Ho, and Ne could indicate lower levels of genetic diversity in these species, low values could also be observed because the InDel markers were developed from two M. domestica cultivars. The lowest He, Ho and Ne values were detected in M. baccata indicating a low level of genetic diversity in this species. Additionally, the phylogenetic analysis and the structure analysis showed less genetic relatedness of M. baccata accessions to the other species. The two subdivisions of M. sieversii, however, showed gene introgression into M. domestica or M. robusta and M. asiatica or M. prunifolia, respectively. These data were highly consistent with the bi-directional gene flow of M. sieversii, which is believed to be the common ancestral species of M. domestica and ancient Chinese apple cultivars [15,69]. M. domestica was domesticated in Central Asia from M. sieversii, but as it migrated westwards, it hybridized with the European crabapple M. sylvestris and/or M. orientalis, from which modern apples are descended [10]. However, the DNA ITS1 sequences and genomic regions used in previous studies were not informative for discriminating the samples of M. sylvestris, M. sieversii, and M. domestica [8,59]. When ancient M. domestica moved eastwards, it hybridized with several local wild or semi-cultivated relatives to created Chinese domesticated landrace cultivars, such as 'Nai', which is highly similar to M. sieversii   and contained a small signature from other wild apple species [15,39]. The close genetic relatedness of M. asiatica or M. prunifolia to M. baccata and M. sieversii identified in this study supports the previous hypothesis that Chinese native species, such as M. asiatica and M. prunifolia, are very likely to be hybrids between M. baccata and M. sieversii [15]. Genetic diversity in domesticated species is often affected by intentional artificial selection and unintentional genetic bottlenecks [9]. Over the last 800 years, M. domestica showed no significant reduction in genetic diversity [23], which can possibly be explained by the wild-to-crop introgression [12]. Interspecific hybridization may be an important mechanism for germplasm diversification, and similar genes across multiple species underlies parallel/convergent phenotypic evolution between taxa [53]. The highest level of genetic diversity among the seven Malus species was observed in M. domestica, indicated by the highest He and Ho. During domestication and evolution, both the modern deliberate selection and past natural selection may gradually change the genetic composition of a species [53]. We found the genetic composition differed among the InDel markers and Malus species.
In this study, the low inbreeding coefficients of all the seven species were consistent with the high level of gametophytic self-incompatibility in Malus [14,42,73]. The lowest inbreeding coefficient was detected for M. domestica and M. asiatica, which could be explained by the artificial selection for cultivars with high levels of heterozygosity [12].
The highest inbreeding coefficient observed among the seven species in this study was in M. baccata. This observation is likely an artifact from our marker development panel, which consisted only of M. domestica accessions. Because M. baccata is rather distantly related to M. domestica [12], our markers were likely not as informative in this species.
In this study, we found relatively high differentiation between M. domestica and the other species. While wild-to-crop gene flow may occur naturally, anthropogenic factors, such as apple production and the variations in apple flower visitors, significantly impact wild-to-crop gene flow [9]. We observed that several accessions of M. asiatica, M. robusta, M. prunifolia, M. sieversii, and M. pumila scattered in the M. domestica clade (Fig. 5b). This is similar to previous findings that showed high levels of introgression from M. domestica detected in M. orientalis (3.2% of hybrids), M. sieversii (14.8%), and M. sylvestris (36.7%) [11]. Conversely, gene flow from domesticated-to-wild accessions or escapes from cultivated M. domestica threatens the fitness and the genetic integrity of wild relatives; therefore, it is important to conserve wild germplasm resources [6,20].
The application of genome-wide InDel markers to delineate the identity signature of Malus accessions Identity signatures of 1018 Malus accessions were created as QR codes using the 102 InDel markers in this study. These QR codes can not only used for DUST within Malus, but also can distinguish some of the bud sports of apple cultivars. Early studies attempted to distinguish bud sports of apple cultivars with amplified fragment length polymorphism markers; however, the efficiency was low [37,76]. Recent studies have had limited success distinguishing clonal mutants because the high levels of clonality or homogeneity among cultivars derived from bud sports [12]. A previous study used two InDel markers to efficiently and specifically distinguish 'Fuji' and its somatic variant 'Benishogun' from four other bud sport cultivars [33]. In this study, the 102 InDel markers discriminated successfully 33.1, 40.0, 43.2, and 71.4% of bud sports of 'Fuji', 'Red Delicious', 'Gala', and 'Golden Delicious'. There would be three reasons why the bud sports cannot be fully distinguishable. The first is that some bud sports are genetically identical due to the parallel or reproducible occurrence of somatic variations in fruit crops [3,29]. The second aspect that hinders the genetic identification of bud sports is chimeric forms of somatic variation in fruit crops [17][18][19]70]. Epigenetic variations may be the third source of clonal differences that have been difficult to be detected genetically [45,61,71].
The application of genome-wide InDel markers for lineage tracing of Malus accessions Many apple cultivars, such as 'Red Delicious', 'Golden Delicious', and 'Ralls Janet', originated from chance seedlings and one or even both parents of these cultivars are unknown [44]. Lineage tracing back of cultivars with unknown parentage has been pioneered in 'Honeycrisp' by SSR markers and SNP linkage maps [4,27]. Most recently, the parent-offspring relationships of 1400 apple cultivars were analyzed with whole-genome SNPs [44]. By using the 102 InDel markers in this study, the previously reported parentage of 66 cultivars was corrected, whereas previously unknown parents of seven cultivars, such as 'Harlikar', were identified (Table 1). To elucidate the pedigree or the genetic background of cultivars with unknown parentage, the cost of using these 102 InDel markers should be lower than the available SNP arrays ( [2,5,27,38];). However, it would be impossible for these InDels to compose haplotypes, as has been done in some previous studies (e.g. [27]), duo to the marker density being too low.

Conclusions
One hundred and two stable co-dominant long InDel markers were developed in Malus. Identity signatures of 1018 Malus accessions were created as QR codes using these markers. The QR codes can not only be used for DUST, but also can efficiently distinguish some bud sports of apple cultivars. These markers were also used in the analysis of parent-offspring relationship to determine the previously unknown parentage. The application of these InDel markers on the genetic structure analysis also provided insight into the genetic relationships among Malus species.

Plant materials
We  (Table  S3). All the plant materials are originally collected and possessed by China Agricultural University and Chinese Academy of Agricultural Science, respectively. The experiments on plants including field investigation and sample collection were performed under institutional guidelines in accordance with local legislation. Young leaf samples were collected and stored on silica gel. The genomic DNA was extracted using the modified CTAB protocol [62].
Calling of SV from previous resequencing data of 'Jonathan' and 'Golden delicious' SV were called using Delly (version 0.8.1) software [54]. The BAM files from the cultivars 'Jonathan' (SRX4380657) and 'Golden Delicious' (SRX4380658) ( [60]; https://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra/?term=PRJNA392908) were fed into the Delly call function with default parameters to call SVs. The distribution of the obtained SVs in the genome of the accessions was presented using Circos (version 0.69-8) software [31].

Selection and genotyping of InDel markers for all accessions
One hundred and seventy InDels with 50-400 bp polymorphic fragments were selected to develop InDel markers, ten InDels were selected in each of the 17 chromosomes. The InDel fragments were validated between 'Jonathan' and 'Golden Delicious' by Sanger sequencing and capillary electrophoresis analysis. Only the markers that were confirmed to produce unique, valid amplified products and were used for further analysis.
The multi-PCR forward primers of each InDel markers were labeled with the fluorescent dyes FAM, HEX, NED, and PET (Table S2). Multi-PCR was performed in a final volume of 10 μL containing 1 μL of DNA template (200 ng), 1 μL of primer mix, 4 μL of 2.5 × Master Mix I (Beijing Microread Genetic Co., Ltd., Beijing, China), and 4 μL of double distilled water (ddH 2 O). The thermocycler conditions were set as follows: pre-incubation at 95°C for 5 min; followed by 35 cycles of 30 s for denaturing at 95°C, 90 s for annealing at 55°C, and 90 s for elongation at 72°C; and a final extension 72°C for 15 min. Amplified products were stored at 12°C until analysis with an ABI3730 XL sequencing system (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). Fragment and sizing analyses were carried out using GeneMapper v.5.0 software (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA), and chromatograms were independently read by two operators.
The identity signature of the accessions was represented by the unique genotype combination of the 102 InDel markers. Then the genotype information from the accessions was used to create a QR code using an online tool (https://cli.im/).

Identification of genetic composition of the InDel markers
For the genetic composition analysis, only the unique 1002 diploid accessions were used and the 78 biallelic InDel markers were selected from all markers and were used in the analysis. The results of genetic composition were visualized by a heatmap using the pheatmap package (https://www.rdocumentation.org/ packages/pheatmap/versions/1.0.12) with default clustering method in R.  (Table S9). Known polyploid accessions were not included here to ensure bi-allele genetic composition. He and Ho were estimated with GenAlEx 6.5 [49,50]. Fst between species was assessed in exact tests using GENEPOP 4.0 [55,57].

Genetic structure analysis
To elucidate the genetic relationship among accessions, a PCA was performed using the pca3d (version 0.10) package in R [72]. A phylogenetic tree was built using the ape (version 5.3) package in R [47]. A population structure analysis was performed using the block relaxation algorithm implemented in ADMIXTURE (version 1.3) software [1]. We generated the associated support files using PLINK (version 1.90) software [52].

Parentage analysis
To determine the parentage of some M. domestica cultivars, the parent-offspring relationships of accessions with one or two unknown parents were analyzed based on the genotype data of the 102 InDel markers using a custom Python script, AppleParentage1.0 software (https://github.com/wangx321/AppleParentage1.0). The confidence parameters were set to > 0.98 (Threshold = 1).