Skip to main content

Table 2 Haplotypes and genotypes of B. × wardii between B. alternifolia and B. crispa at four nuclear genes and the combined chloroplast regions (cpDNA). The code of each haplotype corresponds to those in Fig. 3

From: Natural hybridization between two butterfly bushes in Tibet: dominance of F1 hybrids promotes strong reproductive isolation

Individuals

ETS-B

GapC2

PPR24

PPR123

cpDNA

BHWI1

Ba1(Bw1)

Ba1(Bw1)

Bw6

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc3(Bw2)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc4(Bw5)

Bc2(Bw9)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI2

Bw2

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bw2

Bw5

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bw13

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI3

Bw5

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bw6

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bc5(Bw10)

Bc9(Bw8)

Bc5(Bw10)

Bc2(Bw6)

 

BHWI4

Bw5

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ba2(Bw4)

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bc5(Bw10)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI5

Ba1(Bw1)

Ba1(Bw1)

Bw6

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc3(Bw2)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc4(Bw5)

Bc6(Bw11)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI6

Ba3(Bw3)

Ba1(Bw1)

Bw5

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc3(Bw2)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bw8

Bw8

 

BHWI7

Ba1(Bw1)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bw6

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bw11

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bc2(Bw9)

Bc2(Bw6)

 

BHWI8

Ba1(Bw1)

Ba1(Bw1)

Bw2

Ba2(Bw4)

Bw3

 

Bw13

Bw7

Bc5(Bw10)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI9

Bc3(Bw8)

Bw4

Bw3

Bc3(Bw7)

Bc3(Bw2)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bw4

Bc2(Bw9)

Bw8

 

BHWI10

Ba1(Bw1)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bw2

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bw12

Bc3(Bw3)

Bw8

Bc2(Bw6)

 

BHWI11

Ba1(Bw1)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ba4(Bw7)

Ba2(Bw4)

Bw3

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bc5(Bw10)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI12

Ta1(Bw4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw2, Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Bw2

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bc7(Bw12)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI13

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw2, Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc9(Bw8)

Bc9(Bw14)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI14

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Ba1(Bw1)

Ta1(Tw2,Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Bw3

Bc1(Bw1)

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bw9

Bc2(Bw9)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI15

Bw6

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw2, Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bw3

 

Bc3(Bw8)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bc5(Bw10)

Bc3(Bw7)

 

BHWI16

Ba1(Bw1)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw2, Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Ba1(Bw1, Bc1)

Bw3

 

Bw9

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Bc2(Bw9)

Bc2(Bw6)

 

TJWI1

Tw3

Ta2(Tw3)

Bc1(Tw1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Tw3

Tc3(Tw5)

Tc2(Tw11)

Tc7(Tw5)

 

TJWI2

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta2(Tw3)

Bc1(Tw1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc3(Tw5)

Tc1(Tw9)

Tw4

 

TJWI3

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bc1(Tw1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tw7

Tc2(Tw11)

Tw8

 

TJWI4

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw8

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tw6

Tc2(Tw11)

Tw7

 

TJWI5

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta2(Tw3)

Bc1(Tw1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc4(Tw8, Ta3)

Tc8(Tw15)

Tw10

 

TJWI6

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bc1(Tw1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc4(Tw8, Ta3)

Tc1(Tw9)

Tc4(Tw3)

 

TJWI7

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw7

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc6(Tw10)

Tc8(Tw15)

Tc7(Tw5)

 

TJWI8

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Tw4

Tw7

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Tc5(Tw14)

Tc7(Tw5)

 

TJWI9

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Bc1(Tw1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc4(Tw8, Ta3)

Tw13

Tc7(Tw5)

 

TJWI10

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw4

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc3(Tw5)

Tc1(Tw9)

Tc4(Tw3)

 

TJWI11

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw4

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Tw6

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Tc1(Tw9)

Tc4(Tw3)

 

TJWI12

Tw5

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw4

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc5(Tw9)

Tc1(Tw9)

Tc2(Tw2)

 

TJWI13

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw6

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Tw6

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Tc8(Tw15)

Tc2(Tw2)

 

TJWI15

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw2, Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta6(Tw7)

Tc4(Tw8, Ta3)

Tc8(Tw15)

Tc7(Tw5)

 

TJWI16

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw3

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc4(Tw8, Ta3)

Tw12

Tc7(Tw5)

 

TJWI17

Tc2(Tw2, Bc4)

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw2, Ba1, Bw2, Ja1)

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Tc4(Tw8, Ta3)

Tw10

Tw9

 

TJWI18

Tw4

Ta1(Tw1, Bw2, Bc1, Ja1)

Tw5

Ta1(Tw1)

Ba3(Ta1, Tc1, Tw1)

 

Ta2(Tw1, Tc1, Ba5, Bw7)

Bc6(Bw6, Tw2, Tc1, Kc5)

Tc8(Tw15)

Tc8(Tw6)

 
  1. BHWI1-BHWI16 and TJWI1-TJWI13, 15-18 in the first column are 33 individuals of B. × wardii from the BH and TJ populations, respectively. “Ba”, “Bc” and “Bw” refer to B. alternifolia, B. crispa, and B. × wardii from the BH population, respectively; while “Ta”, “Tc” and “Tw” refer to B. alternifolia, B. crispa, and B. × wardii from the TJ population, respectively. In addition, “Kc” indicates B. crispa from KM and “Ja” indicates B. alternifolia from JZ